FORUMula1.com - F1 Forum

[AKR]

Typical Ferrari lamb can't beat them then ban them

Typical McLaren Donkey. But don't ban McLaren supporters, they are good to talk to. Just ban Bud as you are the rude one who always throws in the personal insults.

Anyway back on topic. I strongly believe the penalty will stand and given Lewis Hamilton's driving it is just and there are not FIA conspiracies.

[Hanwombat]

I have faith in the FIA, esp when it comes to Mclaren

hmmm

[7UpJordan]

I hope McLaren win their appeal, but I have a gut feeling they won't.

[juggles]

doubt they'll win, but for the good of the sport I hope they do. A shocking decision that needs to be reversed.

[8-ball]

The Mclaren fans are clutching at straws. This is the FIA we are talking about they are not going to overturn the decision and Massa will keep his "victory". Ron Dennis is wasting time and should just focus on winning the upcoming races

[bud]

if this FIA was right and just then McLaren would win the appeal! but its not and they wont

[Matkins]

I would like to see the decision over turned because it was poor. But the FIA obviously wanted the penalty put in place and I doubt they've changed their minds about it. However, I voted for "dont know" because of Heisenberg's uncertainty principle.

[darwin dali]

The history of McLaren? I don't really care. And the real reason why I want the appeal to lose is not because I don't like McLaren, it is because I don't like Lewis Hamilton. He is an arrogant prick with a big usta (mouth) who doesn't deserve to win the title for this reason. Had this happened to Heikki, then for some reason I would of probably shared your view McLaren Fan, even though Ferrari and Massa do need the points.

Unless I misread something, I thought the poll was asking if McLaren will win the appeal, and not whether or not each of us wants them to or thinks they should or should not. Disliking Hamilton should have nothing to do with it, either. It's a matter of whether the penalty was right or wrong, and not whether or not Hamilton is a douchebag. He wasn't penalized for being unlikeable, but for an incident with a chicane. The answer to whether the penalty was right or wrong should be the same no matter who had been in that particular scenario, rather than based on the likability of the driver that happened to be there.

Well, I'd argue that the poll doesn't actually deal with whether the penalty was right or wrong as you say. It simply asks whether or not McLaren will win the appeal and the answers will factor in the surroundings in which this decision will be made. So even if one thinks that the penalty was wrong, one could nevertheless come to the conclusion that McLaren will lose the appeal and vote accordingly.

[racechick]

No they wont get there points back.Despite the fact Lewis gave the place back. Despite the fact that Kimmi cut a chicane 3 times. Twice into les source putting moves on Massa and Lewis and towards the end of the race he used the run off at Pouhon and gained speed to pass lewis.All went unpunished. But no Lewis will not get his points back. This is the game we play.And it is why a mcLaren win is worth at least twice a ferrari win.

[darwin dali]

And it is why a mcLaren win is worth at least twice a ferrari win.

[racechick]

And it is why a mcLaren win is worth at least twice a ferrari win.

Did you not read what I wrote?? McLaren do it without FIA intervention.

[darwin dali]

And it is why a mcLaren win is worth at least twice a ferrari win.

Did you not read what I wrote?? McLaren do it without FIA intervention.

Yes my dear, I read it
But your math sucks badly.

[racechick]

And it is why a mcLaren win is worth at least twice a ferrari win.

Did you not read what I wrote?? McLaren do it without FIA intervention.

Yes my dear, I read it
But your math sucks badly.

Oh you think so?? WellI beg to differ. Three ferrari transgresions ignored. OneMcLaren transgression punished. How come my maths sucks?????

[Mikep99]

And it is why a mcLaren win is worth at least twice a ferrari win.

+ 1



And I raise you a

[racechick]

I address you to my previous answer. I think it escaped your notice