FORUMula1.com - F1 Forum

Discuss the sport you love with other motorsport fans

Formula One related discussion.
#95460
Two of the racing veterans of the Formula One circus have reacted with concern to the FIA's latest wave of fundamental rule changes.

The change to the 'gold medals'-style points system for this season has been roundly panned, but it is the duel-rule budget cap idea for 2010 that Fernando Alonso publicly appealed to be 'reconsidered'.

"I don't understand the need to constantly change the rules of this sport," the 2005 and 2006 world champion said.

"I think that these types of decisions can only confuse the fans," the Spaniard added, insisting that the desires of "the teams, the sponsors, the drivers and above all the fans" were ignored by the sport's governing body.

Jarno Trulli, the veteran of 200 races, echoed his former Renault team-mate's view, telling La Stampa that the World Motor Sport Council's decisions this week comprise "many negative factors and no positive" ones.



"It seems to be that Formula One wants to die and we will all have to go and race in some other championship," he is quoted as saying by the newspaper.

Trulli, 34, said the 'gold medals' system runs the risk that if one driver dominates the season as in 2002 and 2004, the championship will be officially over even earlier than usual.

"It is right to try to give the public more, to improve the show, but it shouldn't distort the spirit of Formula One. I am very, very worried," he added.

ven-time World Champion Michael Schumacher has explained how he is 'astonished' at the various rule changes to Formula 1 to come into affect for the next two years, and is shocked that the governing body made several moderations less than two weeks before the start of the new season.



Schumacher, who has attended pre-season tests in both Jerez and Barcelona over the last few weeks, first expressed his worries over the new KERS system which came into affect for 2009: "You have to say that KERS is a risk for all the teams using it, with the new restricted testing regulations. There are, as always, certain question marks before the first races but that's what makes the whole thing so attractive isn't it?"

The German struggled, however, to see the positive side to those rules imposed by the FIA this week: "I doubt the same goes for the new rules given out at such late notice prior to the start of the season," he continued. "It's something which is to me really, well, astonishing, as in previous years when the majority of teams wanted a rule change for a good reason, the FIA always said that it would not be possible in the short-term, or so late before the start of a season."

The new regulations, particularly those surrounding how the championship will be decided, have been met with mixed views by both those in and around Formula 1. "I cannot imagine those changes will help F1, especially regarding the new system to find the champion," Schumacher said on his website. "I cannot see how it makes sense to eventually have a World Champion who could have less points than the runner-up, although I also think it is a good move to try to strengthen the winner's position. Generally we should also make sure that F1 remains the top series of motorsport, also by displaying the competition with the highest levels of technology."

Michael went on to share his views following his spectating at tests: "I have been at tests to get an overview of the situation and can confidently say - let the season begin! I say this as a fan of both motorsports and of Ferrari; the last impressions were that we look pretty good and should be in the position to fight for the World Championship titles.

"The picture to me at the moment is that there are several teams able to be at the front; besides us there are Renault, Toyota, BMW and Williams as well - on the other hand, after Barcelona you clearly have to say that Ross' team was outstanding. They were one second in front, and if they can take that performance into the season they are strong too, even if the big teams will cut that advantage away with time, which is likely. McLaren, at the moment, looks pretty bad." Michael's comments did come, however, before Wednesday's running in Jerez this week which saw Heikki Kovalainen set the third fastest time of anybody there so far this winter.
Last edited by bud on 19 Mar 09, 16:07, edited 1 time in total.
#95465
starting to think this has alot to do with the FIA wanted to show FOTA who's boss.

Only its gonna back fire because there will just be a breakaway


i would love FOTA to breakaway!


Yeh me too but i would wonder about the rules and regs abit, enforcing them etc.

It would be better if FOTA had overall say over the rules for the sport and the FIA just enforced them.
#95474
Does the concord agreement make the teams contractually obligated to stay in F1 for several years? Meaning, If the teams decided to break away at the end of the season, would they be liable contractually to Bernie, much less the FIA.. I'd imagine he would sue the teams. Secondly Bernie is what, close to 80yrs old. What happens if he dies? Where or to whom does the responsibility fall?
#95475
starting to think this has alot to do with the FIA wanted to show FOTA who's boss.

Only its gonna back fire because there will just be a breakaway


i would love FOTA to breakaway!


Yeh me too but i would wonder about the rules and regs abit, enforcing them etc.

It would be better if FOTA had overall say over the rules for the sport and the FIA just enforced them.


That would be the ideal situation as Max and Bernie know nothing about competitive racing. But they have enjoyed power for so long they won't let it go without a fight
#95493
starting to think this has alot to do with the FIA wanted to show FOTA who's boss.

Only its gonna back fire because there will just be a breakaway


i would love FOTA to breakaway!

:cloud9:
It's only a matter or time. The FOTA need to prove to the FIA that this is not their sport. It's a public sport, and they need to do whats in the fans best interest. Which they haven't.

Another massive flaw of the system. A drive could be extra aggresive in going for wins and win the title. But during the season, because he was extra aggressive he made multiple mistakes and had many a spin off, thus he only has the 2nd highest total of points. Therefore everyone complains that the new champion is not worthy, and that the guy with the most points actually did a far far better job.

This needs fixed big time. But at least the FIA will keep the current points system, therefore they can fix they idoitc mistake with 3 races, without any drawbacks.
#95522
Please break away FOTA. Thes idiots have just lost it.
#95523
starting to think this has alot to do with the FIA wanted to show FOTA who's boss.

Only its gonna back fire because there will just be a breakaway


i would love FOTA to breakaway!

:cloud9:
It's only a matter or time. The FOTA need to prove to the FIA that this is not their sport. It's a public sport, and they need to do whats in the fans best interest. Which they haven't.

Another massive flaw of the system. A drive could be extra aggresive in going for wins and win the title. But during the season, because he was extra aggressive he made multiple mistakes and had many a spin off, thus he only has the 2nd highest total of points. Therefore everyone complains that the new champion is not worthy, and that the guy with the most points actually did a far far better job.

This needs fixed big time. But at least the FIA will keep the current points system, therefore they can fix they idoitc mistake with 3 races, without any drawbacks.

And if not, we can always strike out on our own
#95546
I'm rapidly loosing interestin the future of Formula1. Never thought I'd say that.

Picture this, say BrawnGP go all out for the first half of the season, using their entire season's worth of engines just to get them the championship early on. If they then spend the rest of the season blowing up engines and running at the back of the field it won't matter. However, if say Massa and Hamilton had been going at it close behind for the first half of the season, then in first and second for the remainder, it's possible that they could get first and second in the points. Would that really make for a worthy champion if he's only third points wise?

And as for a budget cap, seems like it's an option for now - how long till thay make it mandatory?
Hello, new member here

Yeah, not very active here, unfortunately. Is it […]

See our F1 related articles too!