FORUMula1.com - F1 Forum

Discuss the sport you love with other motorsport fans

Formula One related discussion.
#44312
What do you think ? I for one and sick of hearing this crap but then again I can see why some people on the outside would say it especially in the Shumy Ferrari years.

Is Formula One a boring sport?By Staff Sports Reporter
http://www.theboltonnews.co.uk/sport/boltonsport/display.var.2291749.0.is_formula_one_a_boring_sport.php

Yes, says David Magilton

HOW on earth can anyone get revved up about the slow puncture that purports to be Formula One motor racing?
It should be a turbocharged high octane fuelled sport, full of thrills and spills, but instead we are left with a 200mph procession with car design instead of driver ability the key to reaching the chequered flag first.
F1 followers are faced with a line of cars going round and round with little chance of overtaking and this weekend's Monaco Grand Prix is the worst example, where the race will be won or lost on the practice laps.
Every driver knows he must get on the front of the grid, otherwise he will just have to play follow-my-leader with the rest of the cars, as passing is nigh on possible.
The Monaco weekend may be one of the most glamorous occasions in the sporting calendar, but that is down to the location and the "beautiful people", not, sadly, because of what is happening on the track.
Lewis Hamilton has been an absolute godsend to a sport that was dying on its feet through sheer boredom.
Armchair fans were defecting faster than Gordon Brown supporters before the cool-headed Brit changed all that with the way he rode into town like a knight in a shiny red and white McClaren. He took the sport by storm in his debut year and narrowly missed out on the world crown.
His is an exceptional story that continues to run and, coupled with the McClaren-gate scandal, put the sport back in the headlines in 2007 - but it still papered over the cracks.
Surprise, surprise - what has happened this season? Ferrari, who belatedly got their act together last season to win the world title, are back in pole position, and there is nothing Hamilton or anybody else can do about it.
Finnish World champion Kimi Raikkonen is a shoe-in to retain his title with the Italian team's number two Brazilian Felipe Massa hot favourite to finish in second place unless Hamilton's magic can somehow defy gravity.
It's not about the ability of the drivers, but the quality of the cars.
A sport that relies on the start, pit-stops and tyre compounds to provide the majority of the excitement and even the outcome of a race, needs a complete overhaul.
TV commentators get all excited about whether there will be a one, two or three pit-stop strategy and if a driver will have enough fuel. Well take it from me, he will have enough fuel as he has a computer on board that tells him to the mililitre how much is left in the tank. Have you ever seen car run out of fuel - no - and nor are you likely to.
Bernie Ecclestone, the owner of F1, is busy touting future grand prixs to the highest bidder. That has resulted in several famous circuits falling by the wayside.
Pity he is not concentrating his efforts on ensuring circuits provide passing places.
Now that would be interesting?

No, says Nick Jackson

IT always infuriates me when I hear people say Formula One is boring.
For me, it is probably one of the most fascinating events on the planet. I look forward the the start of each F1 season every year with eager anticipation, wondering which driver or team is going to dominate.
It is even better when there is a Briton vying for the title, which will hopefully continue to be the case this season with Lewis Hamilton in his McLaren.
But I know why it gets slagged off. It is like people who said Bob Dylan could not sing. Most of the people I know who come out with that sort of tripe have never listened to a Dylan album long enough to understand it. And don't get me started about the fools who think legendary 80s band The Smiths are miserable.
It's like any other sport you don't understand, or have not bothered to figure out the rules and nuances of. Lots of women do not like football because they don't get the offside rule, or why occasionally the ball has to be passed back to the goalkeeper.
Even more cannot stand cricket. I remember my sister telling me it was like watching paint dry.
It is - if you have no idea what the laws of the game are.
I remember watching rugby union in my teens and thinking to myself "why do they keep kicking the ball out of play?", certain that it was the most ludicrous spectacle I had ever seen.
Then the light came on, and I figured out that they were kicking for territory. Bingo. Suddenly it all made sense.
This weekend it is the Monaco Grand Prix, which is a highly glamorous event, through the twisting streets of Monte Carlo, and, admittedly, it will be the sort of race that gives fuel to F1's detractors, because overtaking on the circuit is extremely difficult. That said, having watched every one for a number of years, I have seen it done many times - mainly by Michael Schumacher.
But elsewhere circuits have been designed which allow a lot of overtaking opportunities for the drivers.
The key to finding entertainment in F1 is to comprehend what is going on with the pit-stopping strategy. All the cars must refuel and use hard and soft compound tyres. They can stop as many or as few times as possible to gain maximum possible advantage. Lewis Hamilton finished second in Turkey, splitting the two Ferraris of Felipe Massa and Kimi Raikkonen, as a result of a daring three-stop strategy.
I'll be switching my phone off and settling down in front of the telly on Sunday rooting for Hamilton, Jenson Button, and any other Brit in a car.
#44317
I stopped reading less than a third of the way into it. The guy knows so much about Formula One's ethos that he can't even correctly spell the name of one of its greatest marques. :roll:
#44319
It infuriates me as well when people say F1 is boring. F1 is too complicated for idiots who are bland and favor spec series racing. If you think is boring, then dont watch F1 dumbarse!!
#44322
It infuriates me as well when people say F1 is boring. F1 is too complicated for idiots who are bland and favor spec series racing. If you think is boring, then dont watch F1 dumbarse!!

The twat has also missed out on the small point Formula is not just about overtaking, which some people seem to think is the only thing that makes a motor race and has its frequency in other motorsport series completely exaggerated. Formula One is also about glamour, politics, teamwork, technological and engineering innovation and excellence, etc.

Yes, some things in Formula One need looked at, but what is needed is constructive criticism, not the gibberish of a man whose brain consists of a single cell.
#44325
I stopped reading less than a third of the way into it. The guy knows so much about Formula One's ethos that he can't even correctly spell the name of one of its greatest marques. :roll:

I hate it when people spell McLaren as McClaren. It's shoddy journalism.
#44327
what is needed is constructive criticism, not the gibberish of a man whose brain consists of a single cell.


Or of a man who doesnt even watch the sport. I hate it when people badmouth F1, and they havent even watched a race or watch F1.
#44328
for me i do find the lack of on track overtaking, lining up a serious concern, its hard to appreciate drivers skill just by watching them go round a track with many unflattering camera angles which fail to show the skill req,

f1 is also a victim of its own sucess, the best drivers make few mistakes and mistakes are the most visually exciting moments to watch

id say its not really very watchable for just the racing, (unlike touring cars) but the team rivallry, tactics, politics is unique, but unfortunately, this is the part that is making the headlines, and is the most exciting.
it not that 'did you see that overtake/corner?' you talk about anymore, its 'whos got those documents?' 'how bad was that fia decision?'

shame

EDT, as ive mentioned before, i watch for renault more than the racing now
#44331
Armchair fans were defecting faster than Gordon Brown supporters before the cool-headed Brit changed all that with the way he rode into town like a knight in a shiny red and white McClaren. He took the sport by storm in his debut year and narrowly missed out on the world crown.

The guy obviously keeps up to date with the sport- he still thinks McLarens are red and white! Idiot. McLaren fan, when were they last liveried red and white? (is liveried a real word)

al4x, the lack of overtaking is a real concern, but it has been a slippery slope as the cars have relied more and more on aero downforce than mechanical grip.
Hopefully the removal of winglets and introduction of slicks next year will counter it, but I fear its too little too late.
Still, its the most exciting thing to happen between breakfast and dinner on a sunday :wink:
#44342

The guy obviously keeps up to date with the sport- he still thinks McLarens are red and white! Idiot. McLaren fan, when were they last liveried red and white? (is liveried a real word)


Yeah the red and white McCcCLarens eh :lol: the last year for the McMarlboro partnership was in 1996, 1997 saw the West era begin.
#44346
Most people say Baseball is a boring sport too. (I'm from a Baseball country)

F1 is not about the spectacle side of racing. For that you have many other disciplines such as Nascar, DTM, Rally and the spec series.... heck for mullet-sporting, boot n' hat -wearing, BBQ-lovers around the world... 50 guys driving around a fish tank shaped like an oval in a Chevy Nova at full throttle for the race duration... has 'racing' appeal. But F1 is a sport where 2 secs worth of mistakes split over 2 different days deny you the win.

At least the guys (and journalists) who say F1 is boring will be glad someone who speaks his language is getting enough exposure to make for good headlines and interviews... is he dating Miss Granada? or is it Kylie?? ahhhh I heard Angelina was looking for some tickets to the GP.... After all, the coldness of Schumacher, Kimi... and the constant 'for sure' and mispronounciations of the other guys would never make F1 tabloid-friendly. Ah well... finally there is someone hanging from a trapeeze....... :D i'm just kidding guys :) the boy has nice skills. I really enjoy his driving at Monaco. I've been saying this since last year.

On another hand: "Each household appliance is like a new science in my town"... viva Manchester!! :)
#44372
F1 is a great sport and the appeal is the complexities of each team and how they have to win the race. The problem isn't the sport it is tracks. Monaco and hungary are two races where it turns into a procession of cars for 60 ish laps. That is what needs to be addressed; more chances for overtaking by adjusting the cars and tracks. once that is done it will be the best sport in the world
#44373

The guy obviously keeps up to date with the sport- he still thinks McLarens are red and white! Idiot. McLaren fan, when were they last liveried red and white? (is liveried a real word)


Yeah the red and white McCcCLarens eh :lol: the last year for the McMarlboro partnership was in 1996, 1997 saw the West era begin.

True, still, I wouldn't mind seeing McLaren race in red and white again. 8)
what is needed is constructive criticism, not the gibberish of a man whose brain consists of a single cell.


Or of a man who doesnt even watch the sport. I hate it when people badmouth F1, and they havent even watched a race or watch F1.

That too.

See our F1 related articles too!