FORUMula1.com - F1 Forum

Discuss the sport you love with other motorsport fans

Formula One related discussion.
#26873
From autosport.com:

By Jonathan Noble Tuesday, December 11th 2007, 16:31 GMT

The Grand Prix Drivers' Association (GPDA) is going to be asked by David Coulthard to try and help overturn a ban on the use of tyre warmers in Formula One, autosport.com can reveal.

Coulthard has serious concerns that the outlawing of tyre warmers, due to come into force from the start of 2009, will have serious safety implications. Slick tyres are also expected to return to F1 in 2009, although the move is yet to be confirmed.

In the wake of the first batch of slick tyre testing at Jerez in Spain last week, Coulthard fears that the large temperature differentials between the tyres on cars that have had time to get up to full operating speed, and those just out of the pits and warming up, could lead to dangerous variations in the speed of cars on track.

Speaking to autosport.com, Coulthard said: "I am quite concerned about the temperature differential between the cars, especially in qualifying.

"I have talked to quite a few drivers about it and they all shared the same opinion that without the blankets (tyre warmers), when a car from the pits joins the track when other cars are on a hot lap, it is pretty scary. There is such a big difference of speed."

Testing at Jerez in Spain last week suggested that cars on cold slick tyres were several seconds per laps slower than those on warmed-up rubber.

Coulthard also thinks the dangers are increased because the lower temperature of fresh tyres on a car will result in a loss of tyre pressure - which can further exacerbate the speed differential.

He thinks the situation reminds him of the 1994 San Marino Grand Prix, when low tyre pressures after a slow safety car period were believed to have contributed to Ayrton Senna's fatal crash.

"Don't forget the different tyre pressures. The tyres are operating in a very different temperature range, and we are talking about some cars with 20psi and others that have just 14psi. This is another Senna situation."

Coulthard thinks the situation is worrying enough for him that he has vowed to bring it up in the next meeting of the GPDA, which is likely to take place during one of the January tests.

"It is a serious concern for safety," he said. "I am planning to talk it through in the GPDA. There are not more meetings this year, but in the new year this issue has to be discussed."

Despite his reservations about no tyre blankets, Coulthard said he was encouraged by the first experience of slick tyres, and especially how they felt with no traction crash.

"I have driven with and without traction control in several formulas, and clearly it gives us more work," he said. "You need to pay more attention in the corners. But on the slicks, they definitely give you more grip and bring the predictability of the car back.

"But don't forget that I was running in Jerez with 2008 levels of down force. That is not what we will have when we get the slicks (in 2009)."


I have to say I agree with Coulthard on this. Whilst I think that the tracks are much, much safer since since that horrible weekend in 1994, Senna's crash was the first thing I thought of when first reading about these new regulations.

There are other ways to make Formula One more interesting which would be far more effective. We don't need or want silly and potentially dangerous measures like this or the laughable idea of moving aerodynamic devices!
User avatar
By 7UpJordan
#26875
Go for it Coulthard, tyre warmers have been part and parcel of F1 for over 20 years now and we can't afford to just toss them aside, they're there for a reason.
User avatar
By texasmr2
#26876
Yes I also remember watching Gerhard's 'infamous' pit exit. If or when F1 return's to running slick's I will support the use of tire blanket's. I see and understand the good and both the evil side of using them but I feel the good outweighs the bad as the tire's will only be CLOSER too correct operating tempature and a few lap's must be driven before they become 'TRUE". Atleast they wont be driving on 'black ice' so to speak.



http://www.forumula1.com/forum/viewtopi ... ght=#25938
User avatar
By scotty
#26887
I remember seeing that crash of Berger's, that could have been much worse than it was.

I seem to remember he very nearly hit Schumacher or something???
User avatar
By bud
#26903
well i think it will take away overtaking in pit stops
where if you get out 1 second ahead of the car you were previously following your more than likely to be overtaken due to lack of grip. this will hurt the strategits more than anything
i dont see why DC needed to bring up the fateful Senna crash, we have safety car periods now where cars need to keep their tyres warm in which they dont drive around behind the safetycar with tyre blankets on.
User avatar
By Stephen
#26906
I can't understand it, leaving the pits without warm tyres is plain dangerous. Why don't the FIA just ban helmets to slow down the drivers? :roll:
User avatar
By texasmr2
#26912
So true because the cause of Senna's crash was due to a sheared steering shaft not cold tire's.
User avatar
By McLaren Fan
#26917
So true because the cause of Senna's crash was due to a sheared steering shaft not cold tire's.

Sadly, we'll never really know what happened that day. All we have are several possibilities to mull over which to mull.
User avatar
By deMuRe
#26920
So true because the cause of Senna's crash was due to a sheared steering shaft not cold tire's.

Sadly, we'll never really know what happened that day. All we have are several possibilities to mull over which to mull.


I feel sorry for Frank having to edure 5 years of court over that one.

Accidents happen in F1, things break, drivers know the risk.
User avatar
By bud
#26922
I feel sorry for Frank having to edure 5 years of court over that one.

Accidents happen in F1, things break, drivers know the risk.


Italians.......
User avatar
By madbrad
#26935
So true because the cause of Senna's crash was due to a sheared steering shaft not cold tire's.

I respectfully disagree. I believe the shaft did not break before the accident, and I believe he had a lower ride height due to cooler tires arisen from the safety car period, and that low ride height caused the car to bottom out and lose all grip in the rear. I believe what I believe after studying ALL the findings I have been able to get my hands on, not from media reports.
I am not saying the shaft did not break before the impact with the wall though.
It's important to note the fatal injury was a freak occurence after the wall impact(the object to the head) and the accident itself was rather mundane and almost routine by F1 standards, and would easily be a walk away from incident if not for the aforementioned freak occurrence, which would mean there's no reason to care why the car left the track. Also there aren't near as many wall to hit in F1 anymore.

Anyway, I do think it's dangerous to leave a pit on cold tires. These days the only way a man can get hurt in an F1 car is in a Zanardi style T bone, and Berger showed This is what we can expect. Oh yah and also a Coulthard style swoop over, which just goes to show that they can't prevent every tragedy.
User avatar
By Martin
#26949
I agree, tyre warmers are essential, but, I do like the idea of slicks and lower down force. Less down force = less dirty air = more overtaking opportunities,
I think that the FIA should pay a lot more attention to ways of reducing dirty air.
User avatar
By f1usa
#26950
David Coulthard is right to persue tyre warmer u-turn. The FIA does not make rule changes unless it's benificial to Ferrari. Ferrari has come with a way to put heat into tyres without tyre warmers. Try this expeirment at home, take your rubber bathtub stopper and remove metal ring and chain. Put in micro-wave over for 15 seconds, then feel temperature change. Do this two more times in 15 second intervals. At 45 seconds rubber stopper is extremely warm. F1 teams are on the leading edge innovation and high technology. You can direct and focus micro-wave energy to warm up tyres. If I thought of this, you know F1 teams could do it until they get caught, RIGHT FERRARI.

See our F1 related articles too!