Rate the Drivers

Rate the Drivers#351202

By cheekybru - 23 Mar 13, 14:01

- 23 Mar 13, 14:01#351202

ok so i was thinking of a litte idea, thought id try it out

Send me a private message with your top ten drivers (talent/speed wise) and i shall score them (1 point for 10th driver up to 10 points for 1st driver) il put all the scores together and post the results here once enough people have msged me

SO yeh, lets see if anyone pms or if this flops more than a MS comeback :thumbup:

"I wonder what would of happend if you put Adrian Newey and Lewis Hamilton together, Mclaren had that chance before they let both of them go" - Martin Brundle USA GP 2012

"How is he doing this?!" DC on Lewis - Barhain 2014

Re: Rate the Drivers#351203

By andrew - 23 Mar 13, 14:07

- 23 Mar 13, 14:07#351203

You begging for PMs? :rofl:

Why not just post ratings in the thread? It'll save you getting masses of PMs.

Re: Rate the Drivers#351205

By cheekybru - 23 Mar 13, 14:12

- 23 Mar 13, 14:12#351205

You begging for PMs?

Why not just post ratings in the thread? It'll save you getting masses of PMs.

Quite possibly

i went for pm because it saves people worrying about what everyone thinks and possibly ensures a fairer vote? if people wanna post them here thats fine il post mine to get people started but if people want to pm and remain anonymous i will still include them in the final scores

Hamilton – 10
Alonso – 9
Raikonnen – 8
Vettel – 7
Rosberg – 6
Massa – 5
Grosjean – 4
Button – 3
Perez – 2
Hulkenburg - 1

(when thinking about it working out what to rate them on (Speed/consistency/experience etc) i have just gone for putting them in order of who i would have in my team (ie take everything into account apart from money)

"I wonder what would of happend if you put Adrian Newey and Lewis Hamilton together, Mclaren had that chance before they let both of them go" - Martin Brundle USA GP 2012

"How is he doing this?!" DC on Lewis - Barhain 2014

Re: Rate the Drivers#351209

By Hammer278 - 23 Mar 13, 14:51

- 23 Mar 13, 14:51#351209

Why won't people be honest about their ratings? Don't think PMs are necessary...

Drivers I'd have in my team in order:

Hamilton – 10
Raikkonnen – 9
Rosberg – 8
Alonso - 7
Vettel – 6
Sutil - 5
Webber - 4
Massa – 3
Grosjean – 2
Perez - 1

Taking into account talent, versatility, motivation, and most of all, not a trouble making pain in the a*s. So that's where Alonso loses 3 spots for me or he'd be equal with Hamilton.

Breaking News:Lewis Hamilton has officially overtaken The Fonz in race wins. With 88 races less. Lol(Without a specially built blown diffuser, illegal front wing, preferential treatment)

Re: Rate the Drivers#351217

By andrew - 23 Mar 13, 16:07

- 23 Mar 13, 16:07#351217

In descending order.

Vettel
Alonso
Raikkonen
Massa
Rosberg
Button
Sutil
Webber
Hulkenburg
Perez

Re: Rate the Drivers#351219

By racechick - 23 Mar 13, 16:12

- 23 Mar 13, 16:12#351219

In descending order.

Vettel
Alonso
Raikkonen
Massa
Rosberg
Button
Sutil
Webber
Hulkenburg
Perez

that was a considered unbiased answer was it? :rofl:

it makes the exercise pointless really if you do that. Shall I just give Vettel a zero to even things up? No I won't because he's bette than that :rolleyes:

You can fool all the people some of the time, and some of the people all the time, but you cannot fool all the people all the time.
Abe Lincoln

Nearly all men can stand adversity, but if you want to test a man's character, give him power. Abe Lincoln

Re: Rate the Drivers#351220

By Hammer278 - 23 Mar 13, 16:13

- 23 Mar 13, 16:13#351220

In descending order.

Vettel
Alonso
Raikkonen
Massa
Rosberg
Button
Sutil
Webber
Hulkenburg
Perez

that was a considered unbiased answer was it?

Are you like, surprised or something? :hehe:

Breaking News:Lewis Hamilton has officially overtaken The Fonz in race wins. With 88 races less. Lol(Without a specially built blown diffuser, illegal front wing, preferential treatment)

Re: Rate the Drivers#351221

By racechick - 23 Mar 13, 16:15

- 23 Mar 13, 16:15#351221

In descending order.

Vettel
Alonso
Raikkonen
Massa
Rosberg
Button
Sutil
Webber
Hulkenburg
Perez

that was a considered unbiased answer was it?

Are you like, surprised or something?

No not really. I was hoping to be pleasantly surprised but alas.....

You can fool all the people some of the time, and some of the people all the time, but you cannot fool all the people all the time.
Abe Lincoln

Nearly all men can stand adversity, but if you want to test a man's character, give him power. Abe Lincoln

Re: Rate the Drivers#351222

By andrew - 23 Mar 13, 16:16

- 23 Mar 13, 16:16#351222

Hmm, pot kettle black much?

No wonder Cheekybru wanted this done via PMs! :rolleyes:

Re: Rate the Drivers#351223

By Hammer278 - 23 Mar 13, 16:16

- 23 Mar 13, 16:16#351223

RC don't hold your breath.

Breaking News:Lewis Hamilton has officially overtaken The Fonz in race wins. With 88 races less. Lol(Without a specially built blown diffuser, illegal front wing, preferential treatment)

Re: Rate the Drivers#351224

By racechick - 23 Mar 13, 16:19

- 23 Mar 13, 16:19#351224

Hmm, pot kettle black much?

No wonder Cheekybru wanted this done via PMs!

What do you mean pot and kettle? I've not given my score yet but when I do it will be done fairly not in a ridiculous way to skew the final score.

You can fool all the people some of the time, and some of the people all the time, but you cannot fool all the people all the time.
Abe Lincoln

Nearly all men can stand adversity, but if you want to test a man's character, give him power. Abe Lincoln

Re: Rate the Drivers#351226

By andrew - 23 Mar 13, 16:24

- 23 Mar 13, 16:24#351226

Hmm, pot kettle black much?

No wonder Cheekybru wanted this done via PMs!

What do you mean pot and kettle? I've not given my score yet but when I do it will be done fairly not in a ridiculous way to skew the final score.

It's my opinion. Why the hell does it upset you so much? I probably won't agree with yours but I'm not going to sit and troll you and tell you your opinion is ridiculous.

Re: Rate the Drivers#351234

By 1Lemon - 23 Mar 13, 16:37

- 23 Mar 13, 16:37#351234

Hamilton V everyone ever in 5...4...3...2...1...

Mark my words, Bottas will be world champion by 2020 - Me 24/11/14

"Inherently, we at Williams just want to win races. We love going motor racing, we have a real passion for it and that never diminishes." Claire Williams

Re: Rate the Drivers#351242

By SingaporeSling - 23 Mar 13, 16:43

- 23 Mar 13, 16:43#351242

Top 5 in no specific order, as it would depend what kind of team I'm setting up:
Alonso
Vettel
Hamilton
Raikkonen
Rosberg
If I need to pair up 2 drivers my ideal pairs would be
Vettel and Kimi
Lewis and Rosberg
Alonso not sure who I would pair him up with probably Vettel if I had to choose

Rest of the top 10 pack and future options:
Sutil
Hulkenberg
Maldonado
Vergne
Perez

Re: Rate the Drivers#351250

By LewEngBridewell - 23 Mar 13, 16:52

- 23 Mar 13, 16:52#351250

In descending order.

Vettel
Alonso
Raikkonen
Massa
Rosberg
Button
Sutil
Webber
Hulkenburg
Perez

that was a considered unbiased answer was it? it makes the exercise pointless really if you do that. Shall I just give Vettel a zero to even things up? No I won't because he's bette than that

Threads like this always go down this VERY well-trodden route.... sigh.......

Race wins:181Drivers' titles:12Constructors' titles:8
Fantasy F1 Team = Bridewell Palace Racing

FORUMula1.com - F1 Forum

Rate the Drivers#351202

Re: Rate the Drivers#351203

Re: Rate the Drivers#351205

Re: Rate the Drivers#351209

Re: Rate the Drivers#351217

Re: Rate the Drivers#351219

Re: Rate the Drivers#351220

Re: Rate the Drivers#351221

Re: Rate the Drivers#351222

Re: Rate the Drivers#351223

Re: Rate the Drivers#351224

Re: Rate the Drivers#351226

Re: Rate the Drivers#351234

Re: Rate the Drivers#351242

Re: Rate the Drivers#351250

About Us

Join us on Twitter @Forumula1