FORUMula1.com - F1 Forum

[LRW]

It's simple... it is the responsibility of the driver EXITING THE PITS to do so SAFELY. Ferrari was gifted a fifth place finish, thank you very much.

I'm just repeating the obvious since everyone is busy discussing the meaningless. The rules are very clear here. There is nothing to discuss.

But at what point has he finished exiting the pits? He was way past the 'pit exit' line on the track...?

[What's Burning?]

It's simple... it is the responsibility of the driver EXITING THE PITS to do so SAFELY. Ferrari was gifted a fifth place finish, thank you very much.

I'm just repeating the obvious since everyone is busy discussing the meaningless. The rules are very clear here. There is nothing to discuss.

But at what point has he finished exiting the pits? He was way past the 'pit exit' line on the track...?

He's the one that has to look at the other cars, not the other cars looking out for him. There was no way for Vergne to make a correction once he was committed to the line.

He made a bonehead move to try and pass both cars and it was EXTREMELY unsafe putting the lives of other drivers at risk. He would have overtaken the Toro Rosso easily in less than a lap being on worn primes and Alonso with new option.

It was a STUPID risk to take and he should have been penalized for it.

[LRW]

I agree completely. Your post just made me wonder at what point is he 'exiting' and the rule of exiting safely applies, and at what point has he 'exited' and therefore normal racing rules apply.

[Jabberwocky]

If Alonso had to leave the track to avoid a collision, why did he keep his foot down hard ?

Because that is the difference between a good and a great driver

Sent from my GT-N7100 using Tapatalk

[What's Burning?]

If Alonso had to leave the track to avoid a collision, why did he keep his foot down hard ?

Because that is the difference between a good and a great driver

Even if it was Hamilton making the bone head move?

[sagi58]

If Alonso had to leave the track to avoid a collision, why did he keep his foot down hard ?

Because that is the difference between a good and a great driver

Even if it was Hamilton making the bone head move?

And, there you have it... no matter what, the discussion always ends up with his name being uttered... by a fan, no less!!

[sagi58]

If Alonso had to leave the track to avoid a collision, why did he keep his foot down hard ?

Because that is the difference between a good and a great driver!!

too true!!

[What's Burning?]

If Alonso had to leave the track to avoid a collision, why did he keep his foot down hard ?

Because that is the difference between a good and a great driver

Even if it was Hamilton making the bone head move?

And, there you have it... no matter what, the discussion always ends up with his name being uttered... by a fan, no less!!

Hmmm... I wonder what the Tifosi would be saying if it was Massa coming out of the pits making the same move.

[1Lemon]

And, there you have it... no matter what, the discussion always ends up with his name being uttered... by a fan, no less!!

Correction:

And, there you have it... no matter what, every discussion always ends up with his name being uttered

[sagi58]

If Alonso had to leave the track to avoid a collision, why did he keep his foot down hard ?

Because that is the difference between a good and a great driver

Even if it was Hamilton making the bone head move?

And, there you have it... no matter what, the discussion always ends up with his name being uttered... by a fan, no less!!

Hmmm... I wonder what the Tifosi would be saying if it was Massa coming out of the pits making the same move.

Pretty much the same thing!! Except, you'd have to pick us up off the floor, administer smelling salts and give us a blood transfusion!!

[sagi58]

And, there you have it... no matter what, the discussion always ends up with his name being uttered... by a fan, no less!!

Correction:

And, there you have it... no matter what, every discussion always ends up with his name being uttered

I stand corrected!!

[Frontrunner]

Just watched the race, it sucked

[Hammer278]

It's simple... it is the responsibility of the driver EXITING THE PITS to do so SAFELY. Ferrari was gifted a fifth place finish, thank you very much.

I'm just repeating the obvious since everyone is busy discussing the meaningless. The rules are very clear here. There is nothing to discuss.

But at what point has he finished exiting the pits? He was way past the 'pit exit' line on the track...?

He's the one that has to look at the other cars, not the other cars looking out for him. There was no way for Vergne to make a correction once he was committed to the line.

He made a bonehead move to try and pass both cars and it was EXTREMELY unsafe putting the lives of other drivers at risk. He would have overtaken the Toro Rosso easily in less than a lap being on worn primes and Alonso with new option.

It was a STUPID risk to take and he should have been penalized for it.

Should have been, but why not? Because it was Ferrari and their 'brand'? Or the stewards felt sorry for Alonso walking in like Hunchback of Notre Dame?

First of all, what no one can argue against is that Alonso GAINED an advantage going off track and overtaking ANOTHER CAR. I don't care if he had to fly over a live volcano to do it, he still managed to gain precious seconds by straightlining that corner and passing. "Avoiding a collision" was an excuse the stewards actually accepted??? F**k off, seriously.

[bud]

It's simple... it is the responsibility of the driver EXITING THE PITS to do so SAFELY. Ferrari was gifted a fifth place finish, thank you very much.

I'm just repeating the obvious since everyone is busy discussing the meaningless. The rules are very clear here. There is nothing to discuss.

But at what point has he finished exiting the pits? He was way past the 'pit exit' line on the track...?

He's the one that has to look at the other cars, not the other cars looking out for him. There was no way for Vergne to make a correction once he was committed to the line.

He made a bonehead move to try and pass both cars and it was EXTREMELY unsafe putting the lives of other drivers at risk. He would have overtaken the Toro Rosso easily in less than a lap being on worn primes and Alonso with new option.

It was a STUPID risk to take and he should have been penalized for it.

These are my thoughts on the matter, we'll said WB. I was surprised by the stewards decision. It seems they are taking into consideration the differing tyre life's of drivers which should not be the case.

[Jabberwocky]

If Alonso had to leave the track to avoid a collision, why did he keep his foot down hard ?

Because that is the difference between a good and a great driver

Even if it was Hamilton making the bone head move?

If he is a great driver, then yes