FORUMula1.com - F1 Forum

Discuss the sport you love with other motorsport fans

User avatar
By stonemonkey
#318790
Grosjean has crashed I believe 7 out of 12 times during the first lap this year. At some point it's no longer crashing, but recklessness, that's why the ban is being handed out.

Going from hardly any penalties or warnings to a straight-up ban is stupid though.
There's a theory that Romain's motion was affected by what Maldo did. Meaning he wouldn't have swerved right like that had Maldo not did what he did. Just saying.
Romain moved over, but stopped moving over before touching Lewis. So there would not have been a problem. Lewis could have moved over. Not that it was his responsibility to do anythign about it. There was room. Just saying. But anyway for a second they were happily motoring along together. So I think the swerve is by this point just a thing of the past. Their wheels were interlocked though and eventually those wheels touched, causing the poorly practised aerobatics. The swerve in that sense didn't cause the contact. So in that sanse Romain isn't as bad as it seems. Not quite as at fault as it would appear, but there is no one else that could reasonably share any blame. So I do agree he should take the blame because he was in that position though.

Well, let's be fair here. Maldonado was long gone by the time the lights went out and Grosjean and the rest of the field started their race. He had a lot of space ahead of him to stay to the left. I think he moved right to not get caught hanging on the outside and losing places there.

There was also not enough space on the right of Grosjean to fit a car. Hamilton could not move over. He was already on the grass and skidding because of Grosjean's action. Whether he'd have crashed into Grosjean straight away or after skidding through the grass wouldn't have made much difference. I think they touched because Hamilton had no room anymore. Having room because the wheels interlock isn't having room, it just means you're lucky to not have hit yet, but it's inevitable you will. The crash was Grosjean's fault in my opinion, it's just a matter of whether it justified a ban.

Hamilton DID have room. You're wrong. Hammy had room on his right, a couple feet of tarmac plus the grass. You can drive on the grass. You aren't guaranteed to spin there. If you're supposed to be a world champion you can drive there without wrecking, otherwise get out of the sport. He chose to race rather than avoid contact. That's his right. I was not referring the the interlocked wheels when I said he had room. That's ridiculous.


You can drive on the grass! 2 wheels on grass on the inside approach to a hairpin with half the field going round the hairpin in front of you, how well can they brake with 2 wheels on tarmac and 2 wheels on grass, or even on the white paint?

Hamilton went straight off the line and when Grosjean got close Hamilton started to move towards the edge of the track, with hindsight it's easy enough to say he could have slowed down earlier but there was a car right behind him and what kind of racing would we have if drivers didn't have the trust in each other and thought 'oh no he's coming across the track towards me I better slow down'.
User avatar
By madbrad
#318804
Why don't you read what I said? We've seen them go on the grass without consequence before and I only said it's possible. Hammy could have done things but didn't. He didn't have to.
User avatar
By stonemonkey
#318805
Why don't you read what I said? We've seen them go on the grass without consequence before and I only said it's possible. Hammy could have done things but didn't. He didn't have to.


I did read what you said

If you're supposed to be a world champion you can drive there without wrecking,


how well can they brake heading for the inside of a hairpin with 2 wheels on tarmac and 2 wheels on grass, or even on the white paint?

What could Hammy have done? At what point does it become apparent that Grosjean is going to do something so stupid and what is Hammy supposed to do with a Force India close behind and Grosjean continuing to move over?
By Big Azza
#318820
I think Hamilton knew that any drastic action he took to avoid Grosjean could've started an even bigger chain reaction behind him. As soon as Grosjean made contact, he did the right thing letting go of the steering wheel. Look at how much the thing moved afterwards... :eek:
User avatar
By stonemonkey
#318825
I think Hamilton knew that any drastic action he took to avoid Grosjean could've started an even bigger chain reaction behind him. As soon as Grosjean made contact, he did the right thing letting go of the steering wheel. Look at how much the thing moved afterwards... :eek:


Yep, as far as I can see the safest thing Hamilton could have done is to move to the edge of the track away from Grosjean but keeping all four tyres on the black stuff and be wary of the cars behind. Anything else would have been dangerous on his part.
By Revvenge
#318853
Why don't you read what I said? We've seen them go on the grass without consequence before and I only said it's possible. Hammy could have done things but didn't. He didn't have to.

Not under braking. Last time someone decided to go on the grass during a race start Liuzzi plowed into a couple of cars at the first chicane at Monza. If Hamilton would've used the grass, it would've had the same results, because he wouldn't be able to slow down, crashing into Grosjean and plowing into other cars at the first corner (probably the same ones he did now). Like you say, you can expect a world champion can drive a car without wrecking. While there's times even they make mistakes, in this case there wasn't much Hamilton could do, apart from slowing down because he thought Grosjean was going to run into him, but who expects that?
User avatar
By racechick
#318873
He would also likely have spun if he'd gone on the grass, it was wet through. There would have been a high risk of an accident on the grass which he was trying to avoid, whilst doing his best to keep over from Grosjean.
User avatar
By LewEngBridewell
#318876
LESSON OF THE DAY

What happens when you put two wheels on the grass, in combat, at the start?

As demonstrated by Vitantonio Liuzzi at Monza, 2011

[youtube]HeZ_LCRdeOg[/youtube]
By What's Burning?
#318886
Um, wasn't there a deluge of biblical proportions the previous two days? Wet grass.
User avatar
By LewEngBridewell
#318887
Um, wasn't there a deluge of biblical proportions the previous two days? Wet grass.


Where, Monza?
By What's Burning?
#318890
Um, wasn't there a deluge of biblical proportions the previous two days? Wet grass.


Where, Monza?

Wait it rained in Monza this coming weekend? I meant Spa last weekend! That's what I get for butting in the middle of a ridiculous allegation of this being avoidable by any means from Lewis. Anyway, WET GRASS in SPA, which would have made the attempt at moving off the track a little more suicidal.

Sigh if only people read threads before commenting. :cloud9:
User avatar
By LewEngBridewell
#318891
Um, wasn't there a deluge of biblical proportions the previous two days? Wet grass.


Where, Monza?

Wait it rained in Monza this coming weekend? I meant Spa last weekend! That's what I get for butting in the middle of a ridiculous allegation. Anyway, WET GRASS in SPA, which would have made the attempt at moving off the track a little more suicidal.

Sigh if only people read threads before commenting. :cloud9:


I thought you were replying to my post. Did you not see it?

Sigh if only people read threads before commenting. :cloud9:
By What's Burning?
#318892
Um, wasn't there a deluge of biblical proportions the previous two days? Wet grass.


Where, Monza?

Wait it rained in Monza this coming weekend? I meant Spa last weekend! That's what I get for butting in the middle of a ridiculous allegation. Anyway, WET GRASS in SPA, which would have made the attempt at moving off the track a little more suicidal.

Sigh if only people read threads before commenting. :cloud9:


I thought you were replying to my post. Did you not see it?

Sigh if only people read threads before commenting. :cloud9:

Tushy... I mean touche. Went back and clarified my post since I knew you'd misunderstand it. :wink:
User avatar
By LewEngBridewell
#318893
Um, wasn't there a deluge of biblical proportions the previous two days? Wet grass.


Where, Monza?

Wait it rained in Monza this coming weekend? I meant Spa last weekend! That's what I get for butting in the middle of a ridiculous allegation. Anyway, WET GRASS in SPA, which would have made the attempt at moving off the track a little more suicidal.

Sigh if only people read threads before commenting. :cloud9:


I thought you were replying to my post. Did you not see it?

Sigh if only people read threads before commenting. :cloud9:

Tushy... I mean touche. Went back and clarified my post since I knew you'd misunderstand it. :wink:


You know me too well. :wink:
By What's Burning?
#318894
Um, wasn't there a deluge of biblical proportions the previous two days? Wet grass.


Where, Monza?

Wait it rained in Monza this coming weekend? I meant Spa last weekend! That's what I get for butting in the middle of a ridiculous allegation. Anyway, WET GRASS in SPA, which would have made the attempt at moving off the track a little more suicidal.

Sigh if only people read threads before commenting. :cloud9:


I thought you were replying to my post. Did you not see it?

Sigh if only people read threads before commenting. :cloud9:

Tushy... I mean touche. Went back and clarified my post since I knew you'd misunderstand it. :wink:


You know me too well. :wink:

The life of a moderator... walking on eggshells some eggs are better than others though.
  • 1
  • 9
  • 10
  • 11
  • 12
  • 13
  • 27

See our F1 related articles too!