FORUMula1.com - F1 Forum

Discuss the sport you love with other motorsport fans

Formula One related discussion.
User avatar
By FerrariFan63
#77405
What would happen if: Massa wins and LH is sixth, or Massa comes second and LH is eighth, and something illegal is found on one of the cars between them. Would they allow the championship to be decided by a scruitineering decision?
User avatar
By AKR
#77407
If I were a McLaren fan who believes a conspiracy exists, then I would say if Massa were caught cheating nothing would happen, but if it is Lewis Hamilton that gets caught cheating then he and McLaren will be in BIG trouble because the FIA is anti-McLaren...............
#77410
If I were a McLaren fan who believes a conspiracy exists, then I would say if Massa were caught cheating nothing would happen, but if it is Lewis Hamilton that gets caught cheating then he and McLaren will be in BIG trouble because the FIA is anti-McLaren...............


Well, yes, there would be those who would attribute action or inaction to conspiracy. But I'm curious to know what people think from the point of view of allowing the championship to be decided by a scruitineering decision. As I'm personally sure the FIA would not want this to happen. And it could go either way. Let's say that Alonso is first, Massa is second, and Hamilton is sixth. Championship to Hamilton. Except, what if something is found to be wrong with FA's car?

But my question was specifically not about Massa or Hamilton being caught cheating, but one of the cars between them in the finishing order.

I've got a thread I'm going to create on conspiracy theories saved up for after the race.
User avatar
By AKR
#77412
If I were a McLaren fan who believes a conspiracy exists, then I would say if Massa were caught cheating nothing would happen, but if it is Lewis Hamilton that gets caught cheating then he and McLaren will be in BIG trouble because the FIA is anti-McLaren...............


Well, yes, there would be those who would attribute action or inaction to conspiracy. But I'm curious to know what people think from the point of view of allowing the championship to be decided by a scruitineering decision. As I'm personally sure the FIA would not want this to happen. And it could go either way. Let's say that Alonso is first, Massa is second, and Hamilton is sixth. Championship to Hamilton. Except, what if something is found to be wrong with FA's car?

But my question was specifically not about Massa or Hamilton being caught cheating, but one of the cars between them in the finishing order.

I've got a thread I'm going to create on conspiracy theories saved up for after the race.


Oh I see and understand this now. Well last season the 3 BMWs and 1 Williams that finished between the 2 Ferraris plus Alonso and Lewis Hamilton on the other end were allegedly using cold fuel. Because disqualifing them would of ruined Ferrari's Kimi Raikkonen's title then it was dismissed. Had it been the other way around, Lewis Hamilton would of gotten penalised. This is what McLarenites want me to believe. So in the case of Massa first and Lewis Hamilton 6th or Massa 2nd and Lewis Hamilton 8th, if any of the inbetweeners are caught cheating, nothing will happen otherwise newly champion Massa will concede it back to Lewis Hamilton. It will go to court like it did last year and McLaren will lose. Only exception to this is if Massa comes 2nd and Lewis Hamilton 8th and the winner cheats, then they'll be safe to disqualify him as then Massa would win and Lewis Hamilton would be 7th and the result won't change. Again I am going by what McLaren fans want me to believe. The reality is if anyone cheats in between the places of Massa and Lewis Hamilton, the will get penalised and the result on the championship will change in either direction weather it favours Ferrari or McLaren.
By Gaz
#77422
If I were a McLaren fan who believes a conspiracy exists, then I would say if Massa were caught cheating nothing would happen, but if it is Lewis Hamilton that gets caught cheating then he and McLaren will be in BIG trouble because the FIA is anti-McLaren...............


Well, yes, there would be those who would attribute action or inaction to conspiracy. But I'm curious to know what people think from the point of view of allowing the championship to be decided by a scruitineering decision. As I'm personally sure the FIA would not want this to happen. And it could go either way. Let's say that Alonso is first, Massa is second, and Hamilton is sixth. Championship to Hamilton. Except, what if something is found to be wrong with FA's car?

But my question was specifically not about Massa or Hamilton being caught cheating, but one of the cars between them in the finishing order.

I've got a thread I'm going to create on conspiracy theories saved up for after the race.


Oh I see and understand this now. Well last season the 3 BMWs and 1 Williams that finished between the 2 Ferraris plus Alonso and Lewis Hamilton on the other end were allegedly using cold fuel. Because disqualifing them would of ruined Ferrari's Kimi Raikkonen's title then it was dismissed. Had it been the other way around, Lewis Hamilton would of gotten penalised. This is what McLarenites want me to believe. So in the case of Massa first and Lewis Hamilton 6th or Massa 2nd and Lewis Hamilton 8th, if any of the inbetweeners are caught cheating, nothing will happen otherwise newly champion Massa will concede it back to Lewis Hamilton. It will go to court like it did last year and McLaren will lose. Only exception to this is if Massa comes 2nd and Lewis Hamilton 8th and the winner cheats, then they'll be safe to disqualify him as then Massa would win and Lewis Hamilton would be 7th and the result won't change. Again I am going by what McLaren fans want me to believe. The reality is if anyone cheats in between the places of Massa and Lewis Hamilton, the will get penalised and the result on the championship will change in either direction weather it favours Ferrari or McLaren.


Belive what you want just look at the FACTS
User avatar
By AKR
#77429
If I were a McLaren fan who believes a conspiracy exists, then I would say if Massa were caught cheating nothing would happen, but if it is Lewis Hamilton that gets caught cheating then he and McLaren will be in BIG trouble because the FIA is anti-McLaren...............


Well, yes, there would be those who would attribute action or inaction to conspiracy. But I'm curious to know what people think from the point of view of allowing the championship to be decided by a scruitineering decision. As I'm personally sure the FIA would not want this to happen. And it could go either way. Let's say that Alonso is first, Massa is second, and Hamilton is sixth. Championship to Hamilton. Except, what if something is found to be wrong with FA's car?

But my question was specifically not about Massa or Hamilton being caught cheating, but one of the cars between them in the finishing order.

I've got a thread I'm going to create on conspiracy theories saved up for after the race.


Oh I see and understand this now. Well last season the 3 BMWs and 1 Williams that finished between the 2 Ferraris plus Alonso and Lewis Hamilton on the other end were allegedly using cold fuel. Because disqualifing them would of ruined Ferrari's Kimi Raikkonen's title then it was dismissed. Had it been the other way around, Lewis Hamilton would of gotten penalised. This is what McLarenites want me to believe. So in the case of Massa first and Lewis Hamilton 6th or Massa 2nd and Lewis Hamilton 8th, if any of the inbetweeners are caught cheating, nothing will happen otherwise newly champion Massa will concede it back to Lewis Hamilton. It will go to court like it did last year and McLaren will lose. Only exception to this is if Massa comes 2nd and Lewis Hamilton 8th and the winner cheats, then they'll be safe to disqualify him as then Massa would win and Lewis Hamilton would be 7th and the result won't change. Again I am going by what McLaren fans want me to believe. The reality is if anyone cheats in between the places of Massa and Lewis Hamilton, the will get penalised and the result on the championship will change in either direction weather it favours Ferrari or McLaren.


Belive what you want just look at the FACTS


Facts in your fantasy realm, not the actual world we live in. But don't worry about. In a few hours you will have finally gotten your glory after 9 years. Nothing really as long as you McLarenites make it out to be as Ferrari waited 21 years from Schecter to Schumacher. But anyway go have your moment of glory. :(
By dant
#77443
If I were a McLaren fan who believes a conspiracy exists, then I would say if Massa were caught cheating nothing would happen, but if it is Lewis Hamilton that gets caught cheating then he and McLaren will be in BIG trouble because the FIA is anti-McLaren...............


Well, yes, there would be those who would attribute action or inaction to conspiracy. But I'm curious to know what people think from the point of view of allowing the championship to be decided by a scruitineering decision. As I'm personally sure the FIA would not want this to happen. And it could go either way. Let's say that Alonso is first, Massa is second, and Hamilton is sixth. Championship to Hamilton. Except, what if something is found to be wrong with FA's car?

But my question was specifically not about Massa or Hamilton being caught cheating, but one of the cars between them in the finishing order.

I've got a thread I'm going to create on conspiracy theories saved up for after the race.


Oh I see and understand this now. Well last season the 3 BMWs and 1 Williams that finished between the 2 Ferraris plus Alonso and Lewis Hamilton on the other end were allegedly using cold fuel. Because disqualifing them would of ruined Ferrari's Kimi Raikkonen's title then it was dismissed. Had it been the other way around, Lewis Hamilton would of gotten penalised. This is what McLarenites want me to believe. So in the case of Massa first and Lewis Hamilton 6th or Massa 2nd and Lewis Hamilton 8th, if any of the inbetweeners are caught cheating, nothing will happen otherwise newly champion Massa will concede it back to Lewis Hamilton. It will go to court like it did last year and McLaren will lose. Only exception to this is if Massa comes 2nd and Lewis Hamilton 8th and the winner cheats, then they'll be safe to disqualify him as then Massa would win and Lewis Hamilton would be 7th and the result won't change. Again I am going by what McLaren fans want me to believe. The reality is if anyone cheats in between the places of Massa and Lewis Hamilton, the will get penalised and the result on the championship will change in either direction weather it favours Ferrari or McLaren.


Belive what you want just look at the FACTS


Facts in your fantasy realm, not the actual world we live in. But don't worry about. In a few hours you will have finally gotten your glory after 9 years. Nothing really as long as you McLarenites make it out to be as Ferrari waited 21 years from Schecter to Schumacher. But anyway go have your moment of glory. :(


Lets not argue about who waited longer for a title, that is preety pointless and pathetic.

    See our F1 related articles too!