FORUMula1.com - F1 Forum

Discuss the sport you love with other motorsport fans

Formula One related discussion.
#28600
From autosport.com:

By By Jonathan Noble and Steve Cooper Thursday, January 3rd 2008, 10:09 GMT

Leading Formula One drivers have opened talks with the FIA to discuss wet weather safety in 2008, Autosport has learned, amid renewed concerns about racing in the rain without the help of traction control.

Ahead of the launch of the new 2008 cars that have been designed to work without the help of electronic driver aids, a number of Grand Prix drivers have said they are worried about the safety issues of racing them in the rain.

The fears have led to the drivers opening dialogue with F1 race director Charlie Whiting about agreeing on a plan of action in the event of a wet race, so they are in agreement about when it is too dangerous for the event to proceed.

David Coulthard, a leading campaigner for improved safety in F1, told Autosport: "Fernando Alonso aquaplaned off the road in Fuji (last year) - even with TC. The electronics still couldn't support him - and that will happen a lot more without traction control because Formula One engines are very peaky.

"We don't want to see a monstrous shunt where somebody rides over another car, goes into the crowd or has an accident like (Alex) Zanardi [at the Lausitzring in 2001].

"I'm very relaxed about how Charlie operates. He may have made some difficult decisions – but he's only reacting on the information he's had. He doesn't have the spray we have – when you're flat out at 180mph you see simply nothing.

"But I'm confident Charlie will do the right thing based on us helping and advising him – and that's why we've started a dialogue now rather than trying to react afterwards."

Coulthard has found plenty of support for his worries about the wet weather situation.

Honda Racing's Jenson Button told Autosport: "The only worry I have about driving without traction control is racing in wet conditions. It's going to be very dangerous. We couldn't have raced in Fuji (last year) without traction control – there would have been people spinning on the straight."

Ferrari's Felipe Massa added: "In terms of safety, this is a big step backwards. For sure, we will have more accidents and racing in wet conditions will be very dangerous.

"I've spoken with Michael Schumacher and several other drivers and they've told me it will be more dangerous driving a car without TC now than it was in the past. Another race like Fuji would be very dangerous."

But FIA president Max Mosley has played down the drivers' concerns - claiming that the safety of wet weather races will not be any less because of the absence of traction control.

"Driving in the wet is quite dangerous – with or without traction control," he told Autosport. "It's dangerous in the sense that you're likely to go off but you're less likely to hurt yourself because the speeds will be lower. That was always the theory of the grooved tyre because you reduced the grip and the severity of the accident.

"Imagine, in the most extreme circumstances, holding the British Grand Prix at Silverstone on packed snow – nobody would get hurt because nobody would ever get up to enough speed to do any damage!

"It will make it more difficult in the wet – but it's difficult in the wet anyway. And people forget, even the least competent F1 driver is still amazingly good at what he does. And it won't cause any of them much trouble."


More complaining from these people. You would think it's the 70s again with all their complaining. The chance of a serious injury in Formula One is now lower than ever and risk is a part of motor sport. If you don't like it, leave. It's amazing that a time when the sport is safest and most rewarding we are hearing the most complaints from drivers.
User avatar
By Flyer23
#28603
These cry babys should have been around when there were 1200 Bhp Turbo cars, no traction control and "H" pattern shifters.......
User avatar
By 7UpJordan
#28614
I think the drivers should all go watch replays of the 1984 Monaco Grand Prix, the only driver that complained about the rain and wanted to stop the race was Prost (who was not very handy in the wet).
User avatar
By darwin dali
#28624
And MM is making a lot of sense for once.
User avatar
By McLaren Fan
#28628
And MM is making a lot of sense for once.

Yes. I read what he said. I'm now going to disinfect my fingers and laptop after typing that. :D
User avatar
By McLaren Fan
#29387
From autosport.com:

Coulthard: TC loss not significant

By Jonathan Noble Saturday, January 12th 2008, 14:40 GMT

The absence of engine braking, rather than traction control, will be the biggest factor in spicing up races in Formula One this year.

That is the view of David Coulthard who, after testing, has no doubts about how different things will be on the back of the introduction of the standard ECU in Formula One following the first tests in December.

Although much of the focus has been on the impact that a ban on traction control will make, Coulthard actually thinks that being without engine braking will be much harder to deal with.

And that means drivers are far more likely to make mistakes on the entry to corners, which could increase the chances of overtaking and closer racing.

"The biggest difference will not be traction control, it will be on the other electronic aids that we lose," said Coulthard on stage at the Autosport International Show about what he was expecting from 2008.

"That will affect the car on the entry to the corner, so I expect to see more locking up and more running wide on the entry to corners. That will affect the lap time more than the traction control."

Coulthard believes that the design of modern tyres and the aerodynamic sensitivity of cars are the factors in limiting the impact of a traction control ban.

"I think the traction control, a lot is made of it, but in actual fact with or without it, that is what you do as a driver," he said. "You instinctively make a decision as to how much road you have available on the exit of a corner, whether you have TC or not.

"You want to put as much power as you can through the tyres and onto the race track. So the way the modern F1 car is with radial tyres and aero being so sensitive, you are never going to see huge power slides. It is not a rally car which can go quick sideways. F1 sideways is slow, so I think that won't make a big difference.

"Of course without TC we will see higher tyre wear and the temperature of the rear tyres will be much harder to manage.

"It is easier for an electronic system to maintain the rear wheel slip than it is for a driver, because there will always be a little bit of wheelspin, but with the new single make tyre formula that we have with Bridgestone tyres I don't expect that we will ever be tyre limited to finish a Grand Prix.

"Bridgestone have already won the world championship for 2008 so they don't have to make a tyre that is marginal. They just need to make a tyre that is safe and can supply easily to each of the teams."


Very true, David. Like you, I'm surprised the ban on engine braking has not got more attention.
User avatar
By McLaren Fan
#29448
From autosport.com:

Blundell surprised by TC ban worries

By Steven English Monday, January 14th 2008, 16:49 GMT

Ex-Formula One driver Mark Blundell doesn't believe there's an issue over safety due to the removal of traction control from F1 cars.

The ITV F1 pundit called for the drivers to "just get in and drive."

He said: "I'm surprised that drivers are voicing concerns, particularly the older ones because they've driven cars in the wet without traction control before.

"I'm a bit old school. When I was racing, a driver pressed the pedal on the right as hard as necessary to make the car go faster. If it was raining you just don't press the pedal as hard."

Blundell also supports the move to ban the driver aid from the sport.

"I for one am glad it's going. I think it will show up some drivers' abilities and some drivers' inabilities," he said.
User avatar
By 7UpJordan
#29460
From autosport.com:

Blundell surprised by TC ban worries

By Steven English Monday, January 14th 2008, 16:49 GMT

Ex-Formula One driver Mark Blundell doesn't believe there's an issue over safety due to the removal of traction control from F1 cars.

The ITV F1 pundit called for the drivers to "just get in and drive."

He said: "I'm surprised that drivers are voicing concerns, particularly the older ones because they've driven cars in the wet without traction control before.

"I'm a bit old school. When I was racing, a driver pressed the pedal on the right as hard as necessary to make the car go faster. If it was raining you just don't press the pedal as hard."

Blundell also supports the move to ban the driver aid from the sport.

"I for one am glad it's going. I think it will show up some drivers' abilities and some drivers' inabilities," he said.

He may be chubby, but Blundell's got it spot on, the throttle is not an on/off button, and it's not as if touching the pedal slightly's going to make the car burst off out of control. It's all about trust between the driver and the car.
By bolow
#29463
I agree with Coulthard, it's very dangerous what mad-max doing.
User avatar
By texasmr2
#29477
I agree with Coulthard, it's very dangerous what mad-max doing.

Are they racer's or sissy's???
By al4x
#29478
i think they get paid enough to race without tc, etc

as everyone to take a 10% pay cut and race without tc, i think it wont be so dangerous ;-)

    See our F1 related articles too!