FORUMula1.com - F1 Forum

Discuss the sport you love with other motorsport fans

Formula One related discussion.
User avatar
By vlad
#258372
But his "joke" was just too much! He should watch his words, stop whining and blaming everyone for slowing him down.
But, I still support his move on Massa. Maybe it's not right, but it's brave, and they both continued racing after that curve.
User avatar
By Yoruba
#258373
Can't believe someone can give some much credence to the FIA. They were never prepared for the Hammy type so now they're fumbling on what to do with his talents and skills. Give it em Hammy!!!! Never back down!
#258380
He was slated for options on his first stop but the RBR drivers had "talked over" each other on the radio so the pit crew failed to receive notice Vettel was inbound. Rather than waste more time sorting out the tyre selection, they simply slapped on the primes they had readied for Webber.

I stand corrected. I reviewed the video and I was mistaken. I thought I remembered seeing a red lettered tyre when Vettel was in the pits but it's during Webber's stop that the options are visible. Their stops were so close, I'd thought I was seeing a replay of Vettel's stop when it actually was Webber's.

Which means RBR were gambling they could get 60 laps out of a set of primes. That's beyond audacious, that's positively foolhardy.
By vaptin
#258381
From the video, Webber took a tighter line in than Massa.


Are you sure?
Image


That is precisely my point, look at how Lewis's car is angled compared to Massa, Massa's turning in to make the corner, Lewis was going almost straight. I'd even warrant knocking into Massa saved Lewis there, there was no way Lewis would have made that corner short of virtually stopping.
Can't believe someone can give some much credence to the FIA. They were never prepared for the Hammy type so now they're fumbling on what to do with his talents and skills. Give it em Hammy!!!! Never back down!


What are you on about? He hit two drivers, thats hardly magnificent driving.

Apparently the reaction to Lewis's penalties from the rest of the grid, was thats what you get when you drive like that.

Actually it does look like Massa turned in earlier than Webber, but even if he hadn't, I still see Lewis driving into him. The only way Lewis wouldn't have made contact there was if Massa deliberately moved out of his way.
#258383
He was slated for options on his first stop but the RBR drivers had "talked over" each other on the radio so the pit crew failed to receive notice Vettel was inbound. Rather than waste more time sorting out the tyre selection, they simply slapped on the primes they had readied for Webber.

I stand corrected. I reviewed the video and I was mistaken. I thought I remembered seeing a red lettered tyre when Vettel was in the pits but it's during Webber's stop that the options are visible. Their stops were so close, I'd thought I was seeing a replay of Vettel's stop when it actually was Webber's.

Which means RBR were gambling they could get 60 laps out of a set of primes. That's beyond audacious, that's positively foolhardy.

They did give SV the wrong tires (prime instead of the planned options) and SV lost some valuable time in the process. Thus, the team changed their strategy on the fly from 2 to 1 stops. And SV executed that strategy call in a very mature manner.
By Peng
#258384
That is precisely my point, look at how Lewis's car is angled compared to Massa, Massa's turning in to make the corner, Lewis was going almost straight. I'd even warrant knocking into Massa saved Lewis there, there was no way Lewis would have made that corner short of virtually stopping.


And yet he was going at a slow enough speed when he hit Massa to do no damage? pretty sure he was virtually stopped at that point :p.

If Massa had taken Webbers line Hamilton would have been alongside him or ahead of him at the apex of the corner and Massa could have quite easily driven around Hamilton and probably maintained his position, instead he decided to block Lewis effectively giving him no choice but to either go into the wall or into Massa.

I am glad some people see it and not everyone is blinded by whatever is stopping them from actually watching the incident properly.

It doesn't really matter i guess though as the FIA support most peoples views that the defending driver can do no wrong and the attacking driver needs to literally pass through solid objects at times to overtake or they are at fault.
#258385
He was slated for options on his first stop but the RBR drivers had "talked over" each other on the radio so the pit crew failed to receive notice Vettel was inbound. Rather than waste more time sorting out the tyre selection, they simply slapped on the primes they had readied for Webber.

I stand corrected. I reviewed the video and I was mistaken. I thought I remembered seeing a red lettered tyre when Vettel was in the pits but it's during Webber's stop that the options are visible. Their stops were so close, I'd thought I was seeing a replay of Vettel's stop when it actually was Webber's.

Which means RBR were gambling they could get 60 laps out of a set of primes. That's beyond audacious, that's positively foolhardy.

They did give SV the wrong tires (prime instead of the planned options) and SV lost some valuable time in the process. Thus, the team changed their strategy on the fly from 2 to 1 stops. And SV executed that strategy call in a very mature manner.


for the sake of argument, if Seb did get a set of Mark's tires, is that legal?
Last edited by acosmichippo on 30 May 11, 20:16, edited 2 times in total.
By Peng
#258386
They did give SV the wrong tires (prime instead of the planned options) and SV lost some valuable time in the process. Thus, the team changed their strategy on the fly from 2 to 1 stops. And SV executed that strategy call in a very mature manner.


And he got amazingly lucky that everything that could possibly go in his favour did, turning a failed pitstop and botched strategy that was relying more on luck than anything else into a win.
#258387
He was slated for options on his first stop but the RBR drivers had "talked over" each other on the radio so the pit crew failed to receive notice Vettel was inbound. Rather than waste more time sorting out the tyre selection, they simply slapped on the primes they had readied for Webber.

I stand corrected. I reviewed the video and I was mistaken. I thought I remembered seeing a red lettered tyre when Vettel was in the pits but it's during Webber's stop that the options are visible. Their stops were so close, I'd thought I was seeing a replay of Vettel's stop when it actually was Webber's.

Which means RBR were gambling they could get 60 laps out of a set of primes. That's beyond audacious, that's positively foolhardy.

They did give SV the wrong tires (prime instead of the planned options) and SV lost some valuable time in the process. Thus, the team changed their strategy on the fly from 2 to 1 stops. And SV executed that strategy call in a very mature manner.


for the sake of argument, if Seb did get a set of Mark's tires, is that legal?

No.
#258389
He was slated for options on his first stop but the RBR drivers had "talked over" each other on the radio so the pit crew failed to receive notice Vettel was inbound. Rather than waste more time sorting out the tyre selection, they simply slapped on the primes they had readied for Webber.

I stand corrected. I reviewed the video and I was mistaken. I thought I remembered seeing a red lettered tyre when Vettel was in the pits but it's during Webber's stop that the options are visible. Their stops were so close, I'd thought I was seeing a replay of Vettel's stop when it actually was Webber's.

Which means RBR were gambling they could get 60 laps out of a set of primes. That's beyond audacious, that's positively foolhardy.

They did give SV the wrong tires (prime instead of the planned options) and SV lost some valuable time in the process. Thus, the team changed their strategy on the fly from 2 to 1 stops. And SV executed that strategy call in a very mature manner.


It was impressive to watch. We got robbed of what would likely have been an epic battle at the end...but still it was an impressive performance by Vettel. He is often in here said to be lessor driver in a fantastic car and I admit to wondering about that myself, but then he pulls off something like this weekend. Impressive no matter who is driving.
By vaptin
#258390
That is precisely my point, look at how Lewis's car is angled compared to Massa, Massa's turning in to make the corner, Lewis was going almost straight. I'd even warrant knocking into Massa saved Lewis there, there was no way Lewis would have made that corner short of virtually stopping.


And yet he was going at a slow enough speed when he hit Massa to do no damage? pretty sure he was virtually stopped at that point :p.

If Massa had taken Webbers line Hamilton would have been alongside him or ahead of him at the apex of the corner and Massa could have quite easily driven around Hamilton and probably maintained his position, instead he decided to block Lewis effectively giving him no choice but to either go into the wall or into Massa.

I am glad some people see it and not everyone is blinded by whatever is stopping them from actually watching the incident properly.

It doesn't really matter i guess though as the FIA support most peoples views that the defending driver can do no wrong and the attacking driver needs to literally pass through solid objects at times to overtake or they are at fault.


Hamilton had no line for that corner, he would've run wide regardless, he was going slow because its a slow corner sure, but chances are had Massa been wider Lewis would've also run wide and Massa alongside.

There have been plenty of passes this year which were considerably less risky and reckless. Lewis wasn't along side Massa going into the corner which I think is what happened when Schumacher over took him, Lewis was alongside Massa as Massa was going into the corner. It was Lewis's responsibility to anticipate Massa closing the space.
#258391
They did give SV the wrong tires (prime instead of the planned options) and SV lost some valuable time in the process. Thus, the team changed their strategy on the fly from 2 to 1 stops. And SV executed that strategy call in a very mature manner.


And he got amazingly lucky that everything that could possibly go in his favour did, turning a failed pitstop and botched strategy that was relying more on luck than anything else into a win.

You fail to realize in your analysis that SV as the runaway points leader does not necessarily need to win a race anymore. The worst he could do was stop a second time towards the end of the race if he got passed by FA and possibly JB and he would still end up third and add 15 points. So, that strategy call has to be viewed in that context as well. Under the circumstances, he drove an amazing race and got 57 laps out of a set of prime tires when the common wisdom is that they last only 30-35 laps.
By Peng
#258393
They did give SV the wrong tires (prime instead of the planned options) and SV lost some valuable time in the process. Thus, the team changed their strategy on the fly from 2 to 1 stops. And SV executed that strategy call in a very mature manner.


And he got amazingly lucky that everything that could possibly go in his favour did, turning a failed pitstop and botched strategy that was relying more on luck than anything else into a win.

You fail to realize in your analysis that SV as the runaway points leader does not necessarily need to win a race anymore. The worst he could do was stop a second time towards the end of the race if he got passed by FA and possibly JB and he would still end up third and add 15 points. So, that strategy call has to be viewed in that context as well. Under the circumstances, he drove an amazing race and got 57 laps out of a set of prime tires when the common wisdom is that they last only 30-35 laps.


I didn't say he needed to win the race he was in a comfortable 3rd place and deserved 3rd place, he won the race beating Alonso and Button who both drove much better than him because of luck.

Just an FYI i would have been happy with Alonso 1st, Button 2nd, Vettel 3rd because even though i thought Button drove better than both his pitstop strategy blew his chance at winning and i don't think he would have ever overtaken Alonso.
#258396
...Lewis was alongside Massa as Massa was going into the corner. It was Lewis's responsibility to anticipate Massa closing the space.


But Massa didn't simply "close the space". He started out that way, but there's a point about halfway in where he clearly turned further into Lewis.
  • 1
  • 40
  • 41
  • 42
  • 43
  • 44
  • 59

See our F1 related articles too!