FORUMula1.com

F1 and Motorsport Forums

Dedicated to technical discussion...
#195934
I've looked at every online photo and diagram of McLaren's F-duct I can find and I can't make it work. I can't grasp how this ducted air is causing the wing to stall.

I'm an experienced pilot so I'm fully aware of how and why a wing stalls* and what the consequences of a stall are. That only compounded the problem because I know that a stall also necessarily causes a noticeable vibration as laminar flow turns turbulent and buffets the aerofoil. Part of what was troubling me is that this vibration should be being felt by the driver and could potentially contribute to the wing's structural failure. Even without structural failure but perhaps as dire, buffeting would make the rear end twitchy and reduce the driver's margin of control. In other words, there are potentially catastrophic negative consequences to the stalling of the wing but nowhere have I heard this remarked to.

Today, it occurs to me. I was looking at photos of Ferrari's take on the F-duct and realised there likewise would be a reduction in downforce if instead of inducing a stall, the ducted air were simply accelerated over the top of the rear wing. This effectively would lower the dynamic air pressure over its top, reducing any pressure differential between the two sides and, in turn, reducing lift. All without the negative consequences of a true "stall."

Is this how the F-duct actually functions? Have I been suffering brain-lock because of their mis-use of the term "stall?" Is "stall" an oversimplication someone dreamt up to save the trouble of explaining how it is they're nullifying the wing's Bernoulli effect?

If I'm wrong, please show me where.


*Resulting relevant wind produces an angle of attack in excess of the airfoil's critical angle, causing boundary layer separation
#195940
Fred_C_Dobbs wrote:Because it's a different topic discussing the same device.
So then you agree that the main topic, which is the F-Duct in general and all it's implied positives and negatives is already being discussed? Thanks for clarifying my point :thumbup: .
#195941
I don't agree but I do agree you're within your purview to take that decision. If you will please delete this thread, I'll move to the other.

    Fernando Alonso will be entering his 24th F1 seaso[…]

    Kimi has done it! The youngest ever F1 champion. A[…]

    Williams Support

    It has been a really disappointing season for them[…]

    Austin's F1 circuit.

    COTA is one of the best tracks on the calendar, an[…]

    Swap-in out addons, use only what you really need!