FORUMula1.com - F1 Forum

Discuss the sport you love with other motorsport fans

Dedicated to technical discussion...
User avatar
By volatilis
#144335
If understeer is the inability of a car to take a corner by running wide, why can't oversteer be controlled by putting less of an angle into the wheel?

DO I make sense? I wonder sometimes.
User avatar
By scotty
#144339
Oversteer is when the rear wheels slide out wide relative to the fronts, so it doesn't work like that...
User avatar
By bud
#144342
oversteer can be controlled, infact some corners its essential to get the car/kart on an oversteer enduced angle for better exit speed.
User avatar
By volatilis
#144352
Oversteer is when the rear wheels slide out wide relative to the fronts, so it doesn't work like that...


Yeah, I understand that, but I thought it occurred because when turning in there was too much grip at the front, making the rear wheels slide as the car oversteers into corner too sharply?
User avatar
By bud
#144354
well yeah what scotty said is what youre saying, if the rear wheels slide out while the fronts dont, then that means the fronts have more grip than the rear doesnt it? :hehe:
User avatar
By volatilis
#144357
well yeah what scotty said is what youre saying, if the rear wheels slide out while the fronts dont, then that means the fronts have more grip than the rear doesnt it? :hehe:


yeah, i figured we were saying the same thing, just joe 90 told me it didn't work like that, so was trying to clarify!

i'm just trying to establish if its something the driver can control? when they complain about over steer i just wonder if its because they committed too much to a corner or if its purely an effect of the car.
User avatar
By bud
#144360
well yeah what scotty said is what youre saying, if the rear wheels slide out while the fronts dont, then that means the fronts have more grip than the rear doesnt it? :hehe:


yeah, i figured we were saying the same thing, just joe 90 told me it didn't work like that, so was trying to clarify!

i'm just trying to establish if its something the driver can control? when they complain about over steer i just wonder if its because they committed too much to a corner or if its purely an effect of the car.

yeah it can be controlled, like i said sometimes you want it to oversteer to get better exit speed. It can be from the setup then or from the characteristics of the car itself or even like you said a driver goes in too hot and loses the rear end.
User avatar
By f1ea
#144361
oversteer can be controlled, infact some corners its essential to get the car/kart on an oversteer enduced angle for better exit speed.


i Love rally-style cornering on karts :thumbup:

If understeer is the inability of a car to take a corner by running wide, why can't oversteer be controlled by putting less of an angle into the wheel? DO I make sense? I wonder sometimes.


Well, if the driver put less of an angle he wouldn't be able to make the turn, or he would drift from the ideal line. Unless he goes slower, and we don't want that!
User avatar
By volatilis
#144363
oversteer can be controlled, infact some corners its essential to get the car/kart on an oversteer enduced angle for better exit speed.


i Love rally-style cornering on karts :thumbup:

If understeer is the inability of a car to take a corner by running wide, why can't oversteer be controlled by putting less of an angle into the wheel? DO I make sense? I wonder sometimes.


Well, if the driver put less of an angle he wouldn't be able to make the turn, or he would drift from the ideal line. Unless he goes slower, and we don't want that!


Ok now I'm getting confused.
User avatar
By f1ea
#144370
Ok now I'm getting confused.


You asked (unless i mis-understood!) why the drivers dont change the angle of turning to avoid oversteering.

The reason they dont change the angle is to keep the 'line'. What they have to do is find a balance (set up) that allows them to keep the line at the fastest speed possible, without having understeer/oversteer.
User avatar
By volatilis
#144383
Ok now I'm getting confused.


You asked (unless i mis-understood!) why the drivers dont change the angle of turning to avoid oversteering.

The reason they dont change the angle is to keep the 'line'. What they have to do is find a balance (set up) that allows them to keep the line at the fastest speed possible, without having understeer/oversteer.


But if they are oversteering shouldn't they change the angle of steering to compensate and therefore keep on the line? :)
User avatar
By f1ea
#144395
Ok now I'm getting confused.


You asked (unless i mis-understood!) why the drivers dont change the angle of turning to avoid oversteering.

The reason they dont change the angle is to keep the 'line'. What they have to do is find a balance (set up) that allows them to keep the line at the fastest speed possible, without having understeer/oversteer.


But if they are oversteering shouldn't they change the angle of steering to compensate and therefore keep on the line? :)


If they have to adjust, then they already have a problem. That's the point, they should not need to adjust steering mid-way through the corner to correct oversteer.
User avatar
By volatilis
#144398
Ok now I'm getting confused.


You asked (unless i mis-understood!) why the drivers dont change the angle of turning to avoid oversteering.

The reason they dont change the angle is to keep the 'line'. What they have to do is find a balance (set up) that allows them to keep the line at the fastest speed possible, without having understeer/oversteer.


But if they are oversteering shouldn't they change the angle of steering to compensate and therefore keep on the line? :)


If they have to adjust, then they already have a problem. That's the point, they should not need to adjust steering mid-way through the corner to correct oversteer.


Surely its not possible to set the car up to be perfect in every corner in a race?
User avatar
By f1ea
#144424
Ok now I'm getting confused.


You asked (unless i mis-understood!) why the drivers dont change the angle of turning to avoid oversteering.

The reason they dont change the angle is to keep the 'line'. What they have to do is find a balance (set up) that allows them to keep the line at the fastest speed possible, without having understeer/oversteer.


But if they are oversteering shouldn't they change the angle of steering to compensate and therefore keep on the line? :)


:D
No. They should adjust the car so that it doesnt oversteer. Or at least compromise said corner and allow some oversteering for the sake of better performance on other parts of the track...

Unless it is because of a driver error (ie braking too late, going too fast into the corner, missing the apex etc). In such case, he should not make the mistake.
User avatar
By volatilis
#144545
well yeah what scotty said is what youre saying, if the rear wheels slide out while the fronts dont, then that means the fronts have more grip than the rear doesnt it? :hehe:


yeah, i figured we were saying the same thing, just joe 90 told me it didn't work like that, so was trying to clarify!

i'm just trying to establish if its something the driver can control? when they complain about over steer i just wonder if its because they committed too much to a corner or if its purely an effect of the car.

yeah it can be controlled, like i said sometimes you want it to oversteer to get better exit speed. It can be from the setup then or from the characteristics of the car itself or even like you said a driver goes in too hot and loses the rear end.


interesting. why would i get a better exit speed from an over steer?

See our F1 related articles too!