FORUMula1.com

[adhoc1979]

What are you views on Jonathon Legard? Is he as good or better than James Allen? Or do we need to bring back James? My view is that Jonathon tends to make a lot of mistakes and when something happens on track it takes him ages to react to it by which time its been and gone. Opinions please.

[Gaz]

David Croft.

[stonemonkey]

Jack Dee.

[Denthúl]

David Croft.

I've been very impressed by the Croft/Davidson combination on Five Live. Crofty would do well in the commentary box, in my opinion and, should Brundle leave for some reason, Davidson would be a superb replacement. I would, however, love to see Anthony back in a race car, where he belongs.

[emma]

I haven't made my mind up about Legard... Some things he does / says annoys me, but I can't quite put my finger on why. And he sometimes comes across as a little bored, but that's probably just the way he talks.

[McLaren Fan]

Legard would be good presenting this:

[EwanM]

or this

[adhoc1979]

I think the Croft/Davidson combo is very good. Also Davidsons 'F1 for Dummies' explanations are superb.

[stonemonkey]

I think the Croft/Davidson combo is very good. Also Davidsons 'F1 for Dummies' explanations are superb.

He can go on a bit but I know he's just trying to fill space in the practice sessions. His explanation of the N sticker in the cars was a bit of a ramble.

[EwanM]

I always find Ian Phillips on FP2 to be a laugh.

[Gilles 27]

Croft is excellent. Allen just drove me insane with his tabloid style sensationalism, Hamilton fanboyism amongst other things. i want to give Legard more time and i certainly don't want James Allen back

[Jensonb]

I like Legard. He's prone to repeating himself, but he's decent and unobtrusive. Allen always got in the way, I'm much happier with him as a journo.

[EwanM]

I like Legard. He's prone to repeating himself, but he's decent and unobtrusive. Allen always got in the way, I'm much happier with him as a journo.

And we don't need a repeat of
"GET IN THERE"

[Jensonb]

I like Legard. He's prone to repeating himself, but he's decent and unobtrusive. Allen always got in the way, I'm much happier with him as a journo.

And we don't need a repeat of
"GET IN THERE"

Don't.

Bleeding.

Remind me.

Damn near ruined my good mood. What a tw**

[7UpJordan]

Legard's doing alright in my view. James Allen got annoying a lot of the time, tried to immitate Murray Walker, overtly biased towards Hamilton and comparing him to Senna every 5 minutes etc. But you can't fault Allen for being a good pundit on his website.