FORUMula1.com - F1 Forum

[Thelma_j]

I'd say let them prove everything. Until then.....no comment.

[MAD MAX]

Bit late for the "Deny everthing Baldrick" scenario. Lewis said one thing to the waiting press post race, then it went T**ts up when he told some porkies to the stewards

[Jabberwocky]

Did Dave Ryan know that Lewis was told to move over?

[Jensonb]

Did Dave Ryan know that Lewis was told to move over?

I've been told on forums he was the one who gave the order, but I can't find any confirmation of that. I would have thought Lewis's Race Engineer was the one he was talking to.

[racechick]

Did Dave Ryan know that Lewis was told to move over?

He's the one who told the guy who informs lewis over the radio, so yes I think he knew.

[Frosty]

Did Dave Ryan know that Lewis was told to move over?

Yes he did make the decision to tell Lewis to pull over though he wasn't the one who told him over the radio have a look at this it gives quite a good insight. http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/motorsp ... 981303.stm

[McLaren Fan]

I think lewis is just somone who does as he is told.

The car's gremlins in Brazil, 2007
Crashing into the back of Alonso in Bahrain, 2008
Crashing into the back of Raikkonen in the pit lane in Canada, 2008
Lying to the stewards in Australia, 2009

Hamilton was not to blame for any.

[darwin dali]

I think lewis is just somone who does as he is told.

The car's gremlins in Brazil, 2007
Crashing into the back of Alonso in Bahrain, 2008
Crashing into the back of Raikkonen in the pit lane in Canada, 2008
Lying to the stewards in Australia, 2009

Hamilton was not to blame for any.

and this

[Gaz]

I think lewis is just somone who does as he is told.

The car's gremlins in Brazil, 2007
Crashing into the back of Alonso in Bahrain, 2008
Crashing into the back of Raikkonen in the pit lane in Canada, 2008
Lying to the stewards in Australia, 2009

Hamilton was not to blame for any.

Yeh its not like he didn't just win the WDC or anything?

lol

[racechick]

I think lewis is just somone who does as he is told.

The car's gremlins in Brazil, 2007
Crashing into the back of Alonso in Bahrain, 2008
Crashing into the back of Raikkonen in the pit lane in Canada, 2008
Lying to the stewards in Australia, 2009

Hamilton was not to blame for any.

Yeh its not like he didn't just win the WDC or anything?

lol

Oh and this http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mLGnFTl_6_I

[scotty]

I think lewis is just somone who does as he is told.

The car's gremlins in Brazil, 2007
Crashing into the back of Alonso in Bahrain, 2008
Crashing into the back of Raikkonen in the pit lane in Canada, 2008
Lying to the stewards in Australia, 2009

Hamilton was not to blame for any.

You forgot to mention a very significant incident, Hungary '07... so much for doing what he's told then.

[McLaren Fan]

I think lewis is just somone who does as he is told.

The car's gremlins in Brazil, 2007
Crashing into the back of Alonso in Bahrain, 2008
Crashing into the back of Raikkonen in the pit lane in Canada, 2008
Lying to the stewards in Australia, 2009

Hamilton was not to blame for any.

You forgot to mention a very significant incident, Hungary '07... so much for doing what he's told then.

Yeah, so I did. I'm sure there are other things we could come up if we put our minds to it, such as previous attempts to leave McLaren etc.

[csrracer]

Taken from this interview with Whitmarsh http://www.autosport.com/news/report.php/id/74284

Q. If Davey and Lewis had told the stewards that there was no call to pass Jarno, and yet on the radio transcript it was clear that it was. How come when they came back from the stewards, and even in passing conversation, they did not mention that? And how come no one said, we are going to get busted for that?

MW: It is clearly on the radio, and I think that the questions that were put were Davey interrupted a question that was put to Lewis, so he maintains that they did not answer the question which was: Was he asked to repass? And Lewis was asked, did you slow up to allow Trulli past? And Lewis said no, and at the time he had justified it to himself because as the telemetry later showed, he did not particularly slow up, he pulled over.

The two I am sure were uncomfortable, but we were not aware. And I've said to Davey: Did you deny the radio conversation? And his response on Thursday evening, was dont be ridiculous. Charlie was sat there. Charlie heard it, and it is recorded, how could I have done that? What I believe he did was, when Lewis was asked about it, before Lewis gave an answer, Davey interrupted the questioning and that is the start of this misdirection.

[Gaz]

I think lewis is just somone who does as he is told.

The car's gremlins in Brazil, 2007
Crashing into the back of Alonso in Bahrain, 2008
Crashing into the back of Raikkonen in the pit lane in Canada, 2008
Lying to the stewards in Australia, 2009

Hamilton was not to blame for any.

You forgot to mention a very significant incident, Hungary '07... so much for doing what he's told then.

Yeah, so I did. I'm sure there are other things we could come up if we put our minds to it, such as previous attempts to leave McLaren etc.

Yeh but Lewis didn't actuly LEAVE Mclaren. Your beliving this media BS too much mate because thats all it is. and Hungary 07 was 50/50

He almost won the WDC in 07 and was a dam sight better to the team than that backstabber Alonso who tried everything to get his own way including getting us banned from the WCC.

You said it yourself Renault and Toyota spied also but Mclaren got duck.

Because of him.

Don't get me wrong Alonso is a fantastic driver and he would be good for Mclaren with Hekki but if another good rookie Joins Mclaren were gonna see the same old s*** all over again.

Mclaren get massive massive publicty out of Lewis and they've just got a WDC i don't belive any of this s*** the media are saying about him leaving based on the fact there trying to dam hard to make it the case such as mis quoting haug as i posted before.

[Denthúl]

I think lewis is just somone who does as he is told.

The car's gremlins in Brazil, 2007
Crashing into the back of Alonso in Bahrain, 2008
Crashing into the back of Raikkonen in the pit lane in Canada, 2008
Lying to the stewards in Australia, 2009

Hamilton was not to blame for any.

You forgot to mention a very significant incident, Hungary '07... so much for doing what he's told then.

Yeah, so I did. I'm sure there are other things we could come up if we put our minds to it, such as previous attempts to leave McLaren etc.

Yeh but Lewis didn't actuly LEAVE Mclaren. Your beliving this media BS too much mate because thats all it is. and Hungary 07 was 50/50

He almost won the WDC in 07 and was a dam sight better to the team than that backstabber Alonso who tried everything to get his own way including getting us banned from the WCC.

You said it yourself Renault and Toyota spied also but Mclaren got duck.

Because of him.

Don't get me wrong Alonso is a fantastic driver and he would be good for Mclaren with Hekki but if another good rookie Joins Mclaren were gonna see the same old s*** all over again.

Mclaren get massive massive publicty out of Lewis and they've just got a WDC i don't belive any of this s*** the media are saying about him leaving based on the fact there trying to dam hard to make it the case such as mis quoting haug as i posted before.

You could quite easily say that Lewis lost McLaren both championships at Hungary.