FORUMula1.com - F1 Forum

Discuss the sport you love with other motorsport fans

Celebrate over sixty years of F1 - your memories, experiences and opinions.
By J-Ridd 10
#58875
Being 15 and only having watched f1 since 1995 (i have videos since then as well) i know i may not have as much expierance as some of u guys... Whilst i accept that senna was a tremendous driver and he is high on the list of all time greats, I still beleve Schumacher was better... However i realise that other people have other opinions so i will not bang on about Schumacher being the greatest :D !!!
User avatar
By bud
#58878
so you watched F1 at 2 years of age and knew what you were watching? :hehe: I went to my first GP when i was 5 and i still have memories from it but i do not pretend to know what was going on or who was the best etc at that time!
Though it was there that i had my first impression of Senna, after he crashed infront of my mum and i and hopped over the fence to walk past us :cloud9: This was in 85 and loved his black JPS Lotus, i cried when they to the Camel livery :rofl:
By J-Ridd 10
#58879
so you watched F1 at 2 years of age and knew what you were watching? :hehe: I went to my first GP when i was 5 and i still have memories from it but i do not pretend to know what was going on or who was the best etc at that time!
Though it was there that i had my first impression of Senna, after he crashed infront of my mum and i and hopped over the fence to walk past us :cloud9: This was in 85 and loved his black JPS Lotus, i cried when they to the Camel livery :rofl:

Actually i was 3 and i hav vague recollections of around that time... I still have my schumacher ferrari t-shirt from when i was 6 lol :D
#58882
Being 15 and only having watched f1 since 1995 (i have videos since then as well) i know i may not have as much expierance as some of u guys... Whilst i accept that senna was a tremendous driver and he is high on the list of all time greats, I still beleve Schumacher was better... However i realise that other people have other opinions so i will not bang on about Schumacher being the greatest :D !!!




in my opinion, senna was a better quailfier than a racer. the stats tend to agree with me :65 poles-41 wins.
User avatar
By EwanM
#58890
so you watched F1 at 2 years of age and knew what you were watching? :hehe: I went to my first GP when i was 5 and i still have memories from it but i do not pretend to know what was going on or who was the best etc at that time!
Though it was there that i had my first impression of Senna, after he crashed infront of my mum and i and hopped over the fence to walk past us :cloud9: This was in 85 and loved his black JPS Lotus, i cried when they to the Camel livery :rofl:


See that's why I'm being honest. I was about 6 when I first seriously got into F1. I had watched races the previous year, but didn't really get it. I suppose it took a few more years before I could properly understand the concept.
I maybe not as old and as wise as most on this forum, but hey... every holes a goal:P
User avatar
By McLaren Fan
#58923
in my opinion, senna was a better quailfier than a racer. the stats tend to agree with me :65 poles-41 wins.

Overall, I don't disagree with that. There is a good case to argue that Senna perhaps put in too much effort into qualifying. Also, that Senna pushed too hard in races, which possibly contributed to some of his mechanical failures (although, Formula One was a lot less reliable in Senna's era; Formula One cars are almost bullet proof now). In my view, Senna's biggest weakness was failure to accept there were some races he could not win. He showed he could play the percentage/damage limitation game in 1991, but lapsed back into his old ways in 1994, trying so desperately to win, probably in disbelief at just how bad the Williams FW16 was. Senna pushed too hard in Brazil and spun out trying to win a race that was beyond the car, instead of taking a decent six points which would count for a lot in the championship battle. Schumacher was no doubt a little more race savvy, but it also has to be remember that radio technology was so much better in his era, so a driver could actually have a discussion with his engineer on things such as strategy. In that regard, Schumacher was at a real advantage over drivers in the 1980s and early '90s, for he could converse with Ross Brawn - a strategic genius - who would devise a race strategy for him. Because of that, I rate Prost as the greatest racer, although Schumacher isn't too far behind.
User avatar
By darwin dali
#58925
in my opinion, senna was a better quailfier than a racer. the stats tend to agree with me :65 poles-41 wins.

Overall, I don't disagree with that. There is a good case to argue that Senna perhaps put in too much effort into qualifying. Also, that Senna pushed too hard in races, which possibly contributed to some of his mechanical failures (although, Formula One was a lot less reliable in Senna's era; Formula One cars are almost bullet proof now). In my view, Senna's biggest weakness was failure to accept there were some races he could not win. He showed he could play the percentage/damage limitation game in 1991, but lapsed back into his old ways in 1994, trying so desperately to win, probably in disbelief at just how bad the Williams FW16 was. Senna pushed too hard in Brazil and spun out trying to win a race that was beyond the car, instead of taking a decent six points which would count for a lot in the championship battle. Schumacher was no doubt a little more race savvy, but it also has to be remember that radio technology was so much better in his era, so a driver could actually have a discussion with his engineer on things such as strategy. In that regard, Schumacher was at a real advantage over drivers in the 1980s and early '90s, for he could converse with Ross Brawn - a strategic genius - who would devise a race strategy for him. Because of that, I rate Prost as the greatest racer, although Schumacher isn't too far behind.


Good one. Yeah, AP tends to be forgotten in this comparison, but as you pointed out, when we factor in the circumstances, the professor was an amazing race analyst and deserves credit (and his honorary title).
#59018
in my opinion, senna was a better quailfier than a racer. the stats tend to agree with me :65 poles-41 wins.

Overall, I don't disagree with that. There is a good case to argue that Senna perhaps put in too much effort into qualifying. Also, that Senna pushed too hard in races, which possibly contributed to some of his mechanical failures (although, Formula One was a lot less reliable in Senna's era; Formula One cars are almost bullet proof now). In my view, Senna's biggest weakness was failure to accept there were some races he could not win. He showed he could play the percentage/damage limitation game in 1991, but lapsed back into his old ways in 1994, trying so desperately to win, probably in disbelief at just how bad the Williams FW16 was. Senna pushed too hard in Brazil and spun out trying to win a race that was beyond the car, instead of taking a decent six points which would count for a lot in the championship battle. Schumacher was no doubt a little more race savvy, but it also has to be remember that radio technology was so much better in his era, so a driver could actually have a discussion with his engineer on things such as strategy. In that regard, Schumacher was at a real advantage over drivers in the 1980s and early '90s, for he could converse with Ross Brawn - a strategic genius - who would devise a race strategy for him. Because of that, I rate Prost as the greatest racer, although Schumacher isn't too far behind.


Good one. Yeah, AP tends to be forgotten in this comparison, but as you pointed out, when we factor in the circumstances, the professor was an amazing race analyst and deserves credit (and his honorary title).


Yeah, one shame was that we never saw the two strategic driving geniuses racing against each other when refueling came back in 1994
By Mikep99
#60327
Interesting article.

Schumacher races Senna's memory
http://www.iht.com/articles/2006/05/04/sports/prix.php?page=1
It was supposed to be a duel of titans and a clash of generations, but it ended in tragedy, after Ayrton Senna died in a crash in the third race of the 1994 season, with Michael Schumacher pushing closely behind.

Schumacher won the race and went on to become the most victorious champion in history, breaking all the records. He broke the last big one two weeks ago at the same track where Senna died - in Imola, Italy - passing Senna's record of 65 pole positions. The German won,but this time he was the one tailgated by a young champion, Fernando Alonso.

As Schumacher returns home for the European Grand Prix in Germany on Sunday, having taken Senna's greatest record - Alain Prost and Jim Clark follow with 33 poles - is it finally possible to compare Schumacher and Senna?

Schumacher and Senna only racedeach other from mid-1991 to early 1994. Senna set his pole record in 74 fewer races. While Senna had Prost as a titled opponent and teammate, Schumacher has had no lasting challenger, and no comparable teammate.

Gerhard Berger, one of Senna's teammates, said that had Senna not died, he would hold all the records.
"Formula One would have been the most boring thing that we have ever seen because Senna would have been on pole at every race and would have won every race," Berger said.

Although Schumacher won the first three races in 1994, Senna held pole position at each of them in a Williams that still needed developing, one that would win titles for Damon Hill and Jacques Villeneuve in 1996 and 1997.

"The fact is that Michael it is doing a job like Ayrton did," Berger said.

Although Schumacher and Senna were equally ruthless - both knocked competitors off the track to win titles - they had vastly different approaches.

"Michael's is more a cool German way, an analytical way, and the other one was fully Latin and emotional," Berger said.

While Senna and Prost had a fiery relationship at McLaren in 1988 and 1989, Senna got along with his other teammates yet had a domineering relationship with others in his team.

"As a teammate," said Berger, who befriended Senna, "I realized he was quick on street circuits, quick on quick circuits, quick in the wet, quick in the dry, good in the race, good in qualifying.And I said to myself that this is to be respected and I should not try to find ways to put his performance down or to make his performance look worse."

Schumacher dominates teammates by drawing the team around him. Hehas good relationships with his engineers.

Johnny Herbert said that when he raced with Schumacher at Benetton in

1995, he was frustrated to find that starting with the second race he could not consult Schumacher's data, whereas Schumacher could see his.

"You look at each other's, and you can see where you're better and where your worse," he said. "And I never saw that, and that lasted three or maybe four races. It came back later, but the damage was already done to me."

He said that was more the team's fault than that of Schumacher, whom he respects. He said both Senna and Schumacher were often thought of as difficult by the press because they were so focused during race weekends working on the car that they were often inaccessible.

Nigel Roebuck, a journalist at Autosport magazine, called Senna and Schumacher "absolute autocrats."

"Schumacher has never had a superstar in the other car," he said. "Senna and Prost suffered for it, too, but at least they had the confidence to say 'Well, I don't care who you put in the other car, I'll beat him.'"

Bernard Dudot, head of the Renault engine program in the mid-1980s when Senna raced in a Lotus with a Renault engine and in the mid-1990s when Senna and Schumacher raced with Renault engines at Williams and Benetton, said both were skilled technically. But Schumacher, he said, has a greater understanding of every area - engine, aerodynamics, chassis and tires.

"Michael came up with strong proposals - as a driver, of course; he didn't try to play the engineer - and he knew exactly what he would need," Dudot said. "We did things on the engine at that time that we would never have done - or never have developed - had it not been him.

"Senna imposed more than he proposed. He succeeded, but I think that in a team, Michael adds more than Ayrton, because Ayrton put huge pressure on the engineers. In general, he was not often wrong, but he worked differently, without delegating."
Schumacher also has the stigma of teammates' having to let him win, particularly when Rubens Barrichello was forced to do so in Austria in early 2002.

Berger also helped Senna in 1991, but Senna repaid him at the Japanese Grand Prix in Suzuka, the next-to-last race.

"I had been on pole," Berger said, "but then my exhaust broke, and I had no chance to win, so I slowed and allowed Ayrton to pass. Then, as we came around on the last lap, near the finish line, I saw him slowing down, and I laughed and said, 'O.K., he's running out of fuel or something.' In fact, he was slowing down to give me the victory."
User avatar
By Denthúl
#62339
Although some may have seen this video I would like to share it with those who have not seen it :) .

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wqAmZMV3 ... re=related


You know, I was pretty much in tears when he retired. He was by no means my favourite driver, but for eight years I had watched him pretty much dominate the sport. I think, when he retired, I knew that Formula 1 was going to be different. I mean, I'd seen teams disappear (Jordan, Stewart, Prost, Minardi) and drivers (Hakkinen, Hill, Alesi, Frentzen - I could go on) but this was different. I think that's because of his status. Having never seen any of the other guys that people consider to be the greatest race, this guy has to be the greatest for me.
User avatar
By Ferrarista
#66397
Although some may have seen this video I would like to share it with those who have not seen it :) .

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wqAmZMV3 ... re=related


You know, I was pretty much in tears when he retired. He was by no means my favourite driver, but for eight years I had watched him pretty much dominate the sport. I think, when he retired, I knew that Formula 1 was going to be different. I mean, I'd seen teams disappear (Jordan, Stewart, Prost, Minardi) and drivers (Hakkinen, Hill, Alesi, Frentzen - I could go on) but this was different. I think that's because of his status. Having never seen any of the other guys that people consider to be the greatest race, this guy has to be the greatest for me.


...nothing to add...best in his era ... by far! :)
By ferrari 08
#66698
this mans a legend
he is my favorite driver ever
and now its felippe massa and he is helping him know
hes a great man :clap::clap:
kimi is mad for not wanting micheals help
Last edited by ferrari 08 on 06 Nov 09, 09:32, edited 1 time in total.
By Mikep99
#67240
Another good read

The Loneliness of a Long-Distance Driver
http://atlasf1.autosport.com/98/bel/schumacher.html

The expression on Michael Schumacher's face said it all. Regardless of whether he was right or wrong - the ice cold German was fuming. Schumacher, renowned for his low blood pressure, was already on the verge of explosion when he made his way to the pits in a tricycled Ferrari, after colliding with McLaren's David Coulthard, bringing an end to an almost certain victorious race. "Michael, calm down," was the repeating message from Ross Brawn on the radio, as he observed worriedly the German's personal telemetry showing a higher heartbeat rate than ever.
But Schumacher cannot calm down, not even after three days of a rest at his recently purchased estate in Switzerland. "I could have gone to Monza leading the World Championship by three points, three points!" he says, and it would be a safe bet to say, that Schumacher - who rarely looks back at his own actions - is still reliving the crucial seconds that might eventually cost him this year's title. It would be a safe bet, anyway, for anyone who watched Schumacher prepare in the last couple of weeks for the Belgian Grand Prix.

Hungary's Grand Prix win was a mere surprise, a bonus. The table overturn, in Schumacher's plan, was to happen at his favorite track, Spa Francorchamps. And everything that he did in the last few weeks, was directed at that race on Sunday. "In order to beat the McLarens," wrote Peter Windsor in the latest F1Racing magazine issue, "Michael had to take more risks than most drivers take in a decade." And indeed, Schumacher was never seen - on track and off track - as blindly dedicated to a mission as he was, leading to his eruption in the McLaren's pit garage on Sunday.

The writer Hans Borchert escorted Michael Schumacher in the last three weeks, following him everywhere he went. He spoke to his friends, watched him work-out, test at the Fiorano track, but most of all, watched him in his loneliness. For Schumacher, it seems, is - after all - very much a lonely man, secluded by his roaring ambitions to bring the legendary Italian team Ferrari its first World Championship in nearly two decades. He has the loneliness of a Long-distance Driver, writes Borchert.

There was something in the air during the days leading up to the Belgian Grand Prix in Spa-Francorchamps. Something unmentionable, which gives one the shudders. Racing driver Michael Schumacher, 29, is tempting fate with everything in his power. His commentaries, his driving style, his muscular, well-trained body, his facial features, his every glance betray that this man has just one thing on mind. Close friends have been worried for ages. For the first time in the career of the two-time World Champion they are anxious. "Anxious that Michael will take it too far," is how Jurgen Dilk, one of his early backers, puts it.

Recently he called him and entreated him: "Michael, remember 1994. Think of Ayrton Senna's end at Imola. You are in the same situation. You often overstep the limit."

"I know," replied Schumacher with unusually frank answer, "but I owe it to myself and my team."

"It's crazy the way he rubs his arse down", said one hard-bitten Ferrari worker during the Hungarian 77 laps race. "I admire Michael immensely for the way he handles the pressure," says Sauber driver Jean Alesi, one of the few real friends Schumacher has between the current drivers. "For me, as a racing driver, this is sensational. And the way he handles the extreme curves, how he finds the ideal course, is fantastic. Earlier his style tended to be mathematical, very calculated, like a machine. Now it is all so flowing and quite natural. Only one other has ever driven like this: Ayrton Senna, during his very best time."

But everything has its price. Even for Schumacher. Little by little, he is beginning to show his age. You can read on his face, on every TV monitor, the "I will" and "I must". But occasionally, when you are right up close, like recently on Ferrari's own racing course at Fiorano, the multimillion Dollar face says, "I am so tired."

In three days he ran exactly 1409.4 Kilometers of tests, a record distance for any Formula One driver. And yet, even at Ten at night, after he's been up for over 16 hours, Schumacher has a business meeting with two solicitors from London, their figures throwing long shadows in the light of the full moon as they await the driver to finish his day's course. Later, the three will go off and eat together, to discuss various financial and contract details. But as they await, it is the solicitors yawning rather than Michael. "How he does all this I cannot imagine. Even from just watching I am dead tired," mumbles a Mr Clark.

That is what the days and nights in Fiorano are like. Indeed, it is one of the most curious places on earth; three buildings stand there in the middle of a brown, sun-tanned landscape surrounded by a fence which is as tall as a human-being and is guarded day and night. The whole ensemble was once part of a farming complex, with stables, storage barn and living quarters. In fact, visitors are still greeted by a pottery figure of St Anthony, the patron saint of domestic animals. And right at the entrance there is the white marble bust of the Madonna. Anyone who wants to, can kneel there and cross himself ten times. Schumacher, hardly a religious figure, never does.

Enzo Ferrari made the farm his headquarters in 1972. He had the racing circuit built around it and, in keeping with the taste of the time, installed a filling station. To this day, Enzo Ferrari's office and his small conference room are still kept in the main building. Nothing has been changed, and it looks as if the old boy might slip in sometimes at night and sit right down at the heavy oak desk. Telephone and short-wave radio, even the magnifying-glass reading lamp are all in place, well-dusted and polished up to perfection.

But what would the Commendatore himself have thought of Schumacher? Ferrari elders say he would have admired his driving, but the two would not have befriended. "They would have nothing in common, except the love of racing," says an old guard at Fiorano. Well, Enzo Ferrari is reputed to have built cars in order to impress women, hardly the notion you'd get from watching Schumacher, the opposite of a playboy. Enzo supposedly enjoyed female company until late in his life, and in that very spot where several adventures are reported to have taken place, Michael Schumacher now spends the nights like a hermit.

He sleeps there in the most modest surroundings - a bed, a sofa, a chest of drawers and a sports-bag with very few clothes. The only human companionship he has is his physio-therapist Balbir Singh, sleeping next door. They share a toilet and a shower, but hardly share a conversation; Schumacher is seldom alone, but often very lonely.

But what seems to some so Spartan is actually considered by Schumacher himself a great privilege and absolute luxury. No Ferrari driver before him ever lived in this house and none ever shared what the Commendatore so treasured: the quietness and remoteness Fiorano has to offer. In the former shed where ploughs, harrows and barrows once stood, a complete physical fitness studio has been installed for Schumacher, and the lights are often on until after midnight. And at other times, you can see his shadowy figure jogging all alone along the asphalt track to the accompaniment of grasshoppers chirping. That is what he likes, that is all he can focus on. Anything else is a distraction.

"I do nothing but train and drive," says a very serene Schumacher, "and I have no time for playing around." Indeed, the test program now, shortly before the end of the season, is almost wider than at the beginning of the year. New brakes have to be tried out; shock-absorbers and suspensions have to be checked; new aerodynamic components tested for suitability; and racing situations are simulated.

Then Schumacher goes the whole distance, right to the limit. If any other Grand Prix driver has to endure the full distance once, maybe twice, every fortnight, Schumacher does it twice a week at least. And his Ferrari is looking as if it had been hit by a round of machine-gun fire. All over the carbon-fibre chassis there are gashes and holes, and the mechanics have all sort of things to screw on. Their mutual motto: put the lid on and take it off again. Schumacher's vehicle has had so many adjustments made to it, it is by now referred to as "the mobile building site".

On one of those long testing days, Schumacher was doing over 160 laps - quite a boring sight, really, watching the man punch in a lap after lap, with no Murray to shout at your ear or other drivers to add to the tension. On the small grandstand, in the shade of a plane tree, a few spectators look on wearily. Suddenly, his car slips off the track and ploughs across the adjoining gravel. Everyone wakes up instantly: the fire-service, the paramedics and, above all, the mechanics who are slacking around eating ice creams. They all dash over, but things are already under control - Schumacher disengages and reverses over the grass verge, back onto the track.

Someone says: "You sometimes forget that even here a mistake could cost him his life."

How does he endure it? "Practice," says Michael Schumacher and grins. He says he has for some time now been the equivalent of an experienced professional trucker because this year, with training, tests and races, he has chalked up 30,000 kilometres. At an average speed, remember, of well over 200 kph.

But that is not all. During training he packs his days full of other obligations, including several business meetings, press interviews, sponsorship luncheons and he even manages to fit in four takes for a new Fiat commercial between several test runs.

Michael Schumacher takes life at a breathless pace, always looking vital. But early in the morning, when he is sitting up in his room, he looks weak, his eyes bloodshot from the strain of the previous day. It seems as if he must gather up strength to get going again.

You ask him, "How much is too much?" and also: "How fast is too fast?"

His answer, always the same - "Wait and see."
  • 1
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7

See our F1 related articles too!