- 08 Feb 10, 16:24#184235
Ok Jensonb. Max was totally wrong in his conduct where Flav is concerned. Max should be dealt with in the worst ways allowed legally. I like Flavio tbh. however I feel he should still be charged and punished for his actions. mclaren and spygate ?? that case should stay closed. why draw attention to a issue that costed them more than the actual fine they got.
there's two sides to every story - and then there's the truth as well. From the FIA's position that dont mean mclaren will be exonerated as far as the crime is concerned. they will have every right to revisit the issue as such. the FIA could easily refer the case to a different court and based on all the evidence still be found giulty and may even be given a harsher penalty for going up against the ruling body with the hope of getting away with it. the chance they could be found not giulty of spygate is everybody's guess so based on that angle I dont think they will go anywhere with it.
I think youre missing the point, its about the way the case was handled and the punishment that was dealt. so yeah McLaren has a good shot just as Briatore did.
I understand what you saying Bud but sometimes its best to let sleeping dogs lie because there is major differences between the two cases. Flav had his punishment overturned but I see no reason why his case may not be picked up by another entity that has a vested interest in that case because in no way does it mean that he aint guilty, however it appears he might get away with it based purely on the fact that the fIA rules and guidelines does not appear to cover the situation as completely as it should. I may be wrong as well because I dont know the rules and regs as well as many of you guys.
There only one question that to me is of importance.Q. in both instances was the perpetrators guilty??. A. Yes mclaren admitted that fact to a point. ( please correct me if Im wrong).
We truly had enough drama in F1 that costed teams a lot a bucks and sponsors. I think they should let it go and not wake the neighbourhoods dogs.
It's not about guilt. It's about the conduct of the "legal" system being faulty. To use an extreme example form a real legal system. Imagine a murder, under a legal system where one man (Party Y) is the investigator, judge, jury & executioner. Say that Party X is, in fact, guilty. Parties X & Y dislike eachother intensely already, whilst Party Y needs the family of the deceased to like him. Party Y decides to give the death penalty. I ask, is that a fair outcome, even if Party X did do it?
Ok Jensonb. Max was totally wrong in his conduct where Flav is concerned. Max should be dealt with in the worst ways allowed legally. I like Flavio tbh. however I feel he should still be charged and punished for his actions. mclaren and spygate ?? that case should stay closed. why draw attention to a issue that costed them more than the actual fine they got.
tex
