FORUMula1.com - F1 Forum

Discuss the sport you love with other motorsport fans

Discuss GP2, A1, Rallying, Indycar, Nascar and all other racing series!
#292272
Jean Alesi also racing in Indy 500, definitely won't miss that this year now :thumbup:
#292342
Many formula one has beens have been to indy car ,because the standard is so much lower he might do well,good luck to him.


Absolute nonsense re: the part in bold. The reason that many former F1 drivers do well is because (although this is somewhat changing this year) they are moving from F1 to a spec series so unless they've been at a top team in F1 they will automatically look better because they'll then jump into a car that can only be so much behind the best car on the grid in indycar. If it happens that they came from a mid-grid or backmarker team in F1 they'll then naturally look quicker and be closer to the front in exactly the same way as if they had moved to a quicker team within F1!

I've watched indycar / CART / Champ Car etc. religiously every year since 1993 when Nigel Mansell went there, and especially at the moment with Franchitti, Power, Dixon, Kanaan etc. there is a lot of talent in that field - indeed similar to F1 there are many top racers that simply can't get a seat at the moment. That was the case with Dan Wheldon last year in general before he was killed, where he could only get a seat for a few events, unable to get a full time drive.

The reason that many older drivers do well there is because drivers in general ARE capable of racing beyond their 40th year physically, it's only when the motivation goes that the performance drops off, it's just that F1 has an unhealthy addiction to youth that is not justified on ANY basis.

Sadly, our sport of choice has been dumbed down to the masses to such a great extent over the past decade or two that many fans that have only come on board since then are simply blinded by nonsense such as 'oh, he's over the hill and should make way for fresh blood' by the time they're literally about 33 - as though they are footballers or something.
#292347
Sadly, our sport of choice has been dumbed down to the masses to such a great extent over the past decade or two that many fans that have only come on board since then are simply blinded by nonsense such as 'oh, he's over the hill and should make way for fresh blood' by the time they're literally about 33 - as though they are footballers or something.


"Making way for fresh blood" is not necessarily a bad ideology though. Only 24 seats available and loads and loads of young talent vying for a chance to show what they can do! It's hard enough for them already. If the same drivers stayed in F1 way past 40, then we'd get fewer rookies than ever getting a shot at the big time!
#292367
Sadly, our sport of choice has been dumbed down to the masses to such a great extent over the past decade or two that many fans that have only come on board since then are simply blinded by nonsense such as 'oh, he's over the hill and should make way for fresh blood' by the time they're literally about 33 - as though they are footballers or something.


"Making way for fresh blood" is not necessarily a bad ideology though. Only 24 seats available and loads and loads of young talent vying for a chance to show what they can do! It's hard enough for them already. If the same drivers stayed in F1 way past 40, then we'd get fewer rookies than ever getting a shot at the big time!


Yes it is a bad ideology. It's unfortunate that F1 in many countries is seen as the only form of motorsport to aim for if choosing to pursue a career in racing. There are dozens upon dozens of top level motorsport competitions around the world. Yet young drivers often see it that if they have not made it to F1 then they have failed. This is not the case, nor should that (bad) attitude be encouraged. The ONLY valid argument as far as I am concerned should be based on ability. Age, whether based on somebody being young and 'deserving their chance' PURELY because they are young or have shown potential in a lower formulae (see Jan Magnussen etc.), or based on somebody being old and therefore being 'over the hill' based on poor performances in a poor car that even Vettel or Hamilton would likely do no better in is not acceptable under any circumstances. This is an attitude that should be utterly snuffed out of F1.

See our F1 related articles too!